oppn parties Chanda Kochhar: Khayal Apka or Khayal Apno Ka?

News Snippets

  • Government to introduce PF for self-emplyed and gig workers
  • Crush at Puri Rathyatra leaves 2 dead and 78 injured
  • NEET-UG, marred in controversy due to pape4r leak, saw a huge increase in top scores as two scored 715/720 and 11.2 lkah candidates cleared the exam
  • India's first hydrogen-powered train will be flagged off by PM Modi from Jind in Haryana
  • Delhi HC asks the government to monitor Sona Wnagchuk's health regularly
  • TMC Rajya Sabha MP Koel Mallick resigns from her seat, leaves TMC. Mamata asks all those wishing to leave the party to do so before July 21
  • Calcutta HC says land deed is not a proof of citizenship. Refuses to provide protection to a man facing deportation on basis of land deed
  • Supreme Court tells the government to teach the third language in the 3-language formula in Class 6 and not Class 9
  • Government to take steps to boost liquidity for small businesses
  • RBI says that banks cannot sell seized assets back to the defaulters
  • Centre decides to take equity stakes in semiconductor startups
  • Markets remain flat on Thursday: Sensex closes just 1 point ahead and Nifty ended 5 point lower
  • BCCI:Selectors have possibly decided that Rohit Sharma will not be selected for ODIs after the Lord's game on Sunday
  • Japan Open badminton: P V Sindhu stuns world no. 5 Han Yue of China 21-16, 21-14 to enter the quarterfinals
  • 2nd ODI versus England: Indian batting fails miserably except Gill, Kohli and Iyer to score just 233 all out. England win by 4 wickets
Supreme Court clarifies that it has not issued a blanket ban on use of bulldozers, and they can be used after compliance with procedure laid down in civil laws
oppn parties
Chanda Kochhar: Khayal Apka or Khayal Apno Ka?

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2018-04-04 20:13:11

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator. Author of Cyber Scams in India, Digital Arrest, The Money Trap and The Human Hack
Political interference and corruption have been the undoing of PSU banks. Nepotism might well do the same to private banks in India. The web of deceit surrounding the dealings between Deepak Kochhar, husband of ICICI Bank CEO and MD Chanda Kochhar and Venugopal Dhoot, chairman of Videocon Industries would put any writer of financial thrillers to shame. That Videocon took a loan of Rs 3250cr from ICICI Bank; that Chanda Kochhar sat on the committee that vetted and passed the loan and that the loan later became sticky and has not been paid back in full is known to all. But the way backs were scratched for the deal to materialize is not.

The story in short is this: In 2008, Deepak Kochhar and Venugopal Dhoot jointly promoted a company called NuPower Renewables. In 2010, another company owned by Dhoot gave a loan of Rs 64cr to NuPower. In 2012, ICICI Bank (as part of a consortium) lent Rs 3250cr to Videocon Industries. Shortly thereafter, a trust controlled by Kochhar bought controlling shares of the company that lent Rs 64cr to NuPower for just Rs 9 lakh. Later, Dhoot sold his 50% stake in NuPower to Kochhar for just Rs 2.5 lakh. Between all this, NuPower received Rs 325cr as offshore investment from First Land Holding, an entity based in Mauritius.

The CBI has registered a preliminary enquiry to find out the nexus between Dhoot and Kochhar. The IT Department has sought details of First Land holding from the Kochhars. Now, the Serious Fraud Investigation Office (SFIO) has sought the permission of Ministry of Corporate Affairs to probe the ICICI Bank’s loan to Videocon.

Yet, the chairman of ICICI Bank, MK Sharma, continues to defend Chanda Kochhar and says that an independent enquiry is not necessary. His main defense was that since Videocon was not an investor in NuPower, there was no need for Chanda Kochhar to recuse herself from the sanctioning committee. He also said that since a consortium was involved that had agreed on terms and conditions and since Kochhar had made all necessary disclosures and was not chairing the committee, she has committed no wrong. But that was one week ago. One is sure that after the latest and murkier disclosures and investigations by multiple agencies, even Sharma would be forced to revise his opinion.

Another interesting fact that has come to light is that many of ICICI Banks’ loan clients took restructuring advice from Avista Advisory Group, run by Rajiv Kochhar, Deepak’s brother and Chanda Kochhar’s brother-in-law. While brothers-in-law do not come under the ambit of relatives under the Companies Act and hence no disclosures need to be made, given the ways quid pro quo works in India, this is another angle the investigating agencies would do well to probe deeply.

ICICI Bank is India’s largest private bank and to restore public faith (its shares have tumbled on the bourses), it must have a forensic audit conducted by an independent agency, regardless of the status of the investigations being conducted by government agencies. It must punish the guilty. The future of privately-owned banks depends on the steps ICICI Bank takes to address this issue. Already there are rumblings in Axis Bank about MD & CEO Shikha Sharma after the RBI asked the bank to reconsider its grant of the 4th three year term to her because of bank’s below-average performance and deteriorating asset quality. Hence, as the top private bank, ICICI Bank must take the lead to restore good governance.