oppn parties De-Radicalization Cannot Be A One-Way Street

News Snippets

  • Sensex jumps by 834 points as Biden takes over in the US. Market sees a jump in foreign inflows
  • Canteen subsidy goes in Parliament. ITDC to run the canteen instead of Northern Railways
  • West Bengal government reconstitutes the state poll panel ahead of the visit of the full bench of the Election Commission to the state
  • Supreme Court upholds the amended provision in the Insolvency Code that requires that a minimum of 100 or 10% homebuyers in a project must sign to initiate bankruptcy proceedings against builders for not delivering in time
  • 15 sleeping migrant workers were killed when a speeding truck ran over them near Kim in Surat district of Gujarat
  • A record 11 lakh students have registered with the National Testing Agency for the JEE(Mains) exam this year
  • SC panel on farm laws puts up a portal where individual farmers can give their opinion
  • Congress, NCP and Left demand answers from the government about how Arnab Goswami came to know about the Balakot strikes in advance
  • Government asks Facebook to withdraw new privacy policy for WhatsApp in India
  • Vaccination targets are not being met as low turnout due to fear of adverse reactions and glitches in Co-WIN app throws up problems
  • Shardul Thakur and Washington Sundar keep India in the hunt after a 123-run 7th wicket partnership that allowed Australia a lead of only 33 runs
  • Centre hardens stand on the farm bills, says unions must drop demand for repeal and come up with alternatives
  • Maharashtra Real Estate Appellate Tribunal has ruled that the date of possession given to buyers is binding on builders
  • Visiting Nepalese foreign minister asked to junk the new map of Nepal before any talks to settle the boundary dispute
  • India will buy 21 MiGs and 12 Sukhois from Russia
The Centre and the farm unions to engage in the 10th round of talks today to resolve the farm dispute, little chances of resolution as stands have hardened over the last couple of days
oppn parties
De-Radicalization Cannot Be A One-Way Street

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2020-01-17 13:13:50

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator. Writes for a number of publications.

Asadiddin Owaisi is spot on. CDS General Bipin Rawat has no business giving suggestions such as keeping "radicalized" youth in de-radicalizing camps. Suggesting policy is not the job of army Generals, as Owaisi has rightly pointed out. He is also correct in saying that de-radicalization cannot be a one-way street. Why should we always talk only about the radicalization of Muslim youth and conveniently forget the radicalization that prompts Hindus to kill people like Mohammed Akhlaq and Pehlu Khan and commit other serious offences against Muslims?

Basically, it is the failure of government policy and society as a whole that allows youngsters to be radicalized. No person will submit him of her to radical ideas if he or she is not aggrieved in some way. In Kashmir, the narrative of 'Azadi' from Indian occupational forces, backed obviously by an intertwined religious narrative, attracts the youngsters to become radicals. Then, of course, there is the lure of money (provided to stone-pelters by various organizations from funds sent from across the border) when jobs are hard to come by. Successive governments never even tried to assimilate Kashmir with India. They always thought to pour money to 'manage' the state would solve matters. But that has not happened. Kashmiri society, too, did not think twice before partaking of largesse from the Indian government but never telling their youth not to fall for the games Pakistan was playing. India never ceased to be anything more than an occupying country for them, most of who dreamt of 'freeing' Kashmir from its 'clutches'. Kashmiriyat was always talked about, not Bharatiyata and not even Kashmiriyat as a part of Bharatiyata. That mentality was seized upon by the various separatist groups operating in the Valley, supported and financed by an actively interested Pakistan. The radicalization in Kashmir has been an ongoing process since 1948 and no amount of pandering to the wishes of the Abdullah and Sayed families has reduced it.

But what does one say about the radicalization of those who killed Mohammed Akhlaq and Pehlu Khan? India was never meant to be a Hindu Pakistan. It was designed as a secular democracy where people of all religions, caste, creed and culture could stay together in harmony. A huge majority of the Indian population had accepted it then and the position has not changed even now. This is proved by the way people conduct themselves if politicians, religious leaders and miscreants on both sides of the spectrum do not interfere. But that position is sought to be changed now. Ever since the NDA came to power in 2014, the Hindu chauvinists (one uses this term in an informed way as there is no other way to describe this small minority that is made up  of people of which some think Muslims should “go to Pakistan”  and others who do not think twice before killing those who do not abide by the 'standards' (no beef, no hijab or burqa, no beard, no topi, no namaz on the streets, no loudspeakers in mosques, no loving Hindu girls and, of course, saying "Jai Shree Ram" on demand) they set for them, have sought to undermine the "sabka saath, sabka vikas" model envisaged by Prime Minister Narendra Modi when he was canvassing for votes before receiving the mandate for his first term. The tragedy is that the administration has often given the impression that these Hindu radicals have a free hand in whatever they are doing.

Hence, if radicalization is to be tackled, then it has to be for both Hindus and Muslims. Prime Minister Modi has often said that there are no good or bad terrorists. Terrorists are terrorists whose only aim is to create terror and disharmony between communities. If that is taken as the definition, then the persons who stop Muslims and force them to say "Jai Shree Ram" all over India or those who killed Akhlaq and Khan are equally guilty of terrorism as the persons who pelt stones on security forces in the Kashmir Valley. The government cannot punish one and ignore or downplay the other.