oppn parties Due Process Avoided, Mary Kom's Selection Unfair To Nikhat Zareen

News Snippets

  • Amit Panghal becomes first Indian male to win silver at the World Boxing Championships
  • "Gully Boy" to be India's entry for the Oscars
  • Rajeev Kumar called an "absconder" by the CBI
  • Alipore court refuses to grant anticipatory bail to Rajeev Kumar
  • Trump likely to sign a mini trade deal with India next week
  • Government planning a loan mela to cover 400 districts in two phases
  • PM Modi says Kashmiris need a hug from all Indians
  • NPA tag will not be put on any MSME till March 20
  • Government likely to announce another economic stimulus package today ahead of the GST Council meet in Goa
  • Air Marshall RKS Bhadauria, slated to retire just a few days from now, to be the next chief of IAF
  • PM Modi slams politicians from his own party who are making irresponsible statements on the Ayodhya case and tells them to wait for the Supreme Court order
  • Telecom panel says resident welfare associations (RWA) cannot give monopoly access to any one service provider and infrastructure in public spaces and residential complexes will have to be shared by all
  • Mamata Banerjee meets Amit Shah, tells him there is no need for an NRC in Bengal
  • After 14 days, there is no hope left for reviving Vikram, the moon lander
  • CBI teams search for elusive Rajeev Kumar
PM Modi to address more than 50000 people at the Howdy Modi event in Houston today where he will be joined by the US president Donald Trump
oppn parties
Due Process Avoided, Mary Kom's Selection Unfair To Nikhat Zareen

By Sunil Garodia

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator. Writes for a number of publications.

If a star sportsperson browbeats the sports association to have his or her way, is it good for the sport? The way celebrated boxer Mary Kom was 'selected' for the World Championships without a trial bout in the 51kg category was not good. It went against the prescribed selection process and reeked of highhandedness. It was highly demoralizing for a young boxer like Nikhat Zareen who fancied her chances against Mary Kom in the trial bout. It also showed the Boxing Federation of India (BFI) in a bad light as they cancelled the trials at the last moment. Most observers feel that it was done at the instance of the ageing champion.

As a way of explanation, Rajesh Bhandari chairman of the BFI selection committee said that "we received a representation from Mary Kom's coach Chotte Lal Yadav and we all came to the conclusion that Mary has performed consistently in this weight category and has the experience and performance." Which coach will put down his protege? Chotte Lal Yadav would always recommend Mary's name. But he is not the chairman of the selection committee. In any case, due process should have been followed and trials should have been held to allow a young boxer to prove her mettle. The BFI also said that it did not want to expose Zareen at the World Championships at a young age. But Zareen pointed out that she was part of the team for the same event in 2016 and she has grown three years older now.

The BFI further claimed that the 36-year-old Mary Kom is in the form of her life and that Zareen's performances at the camp have been below par. There is no doubt Mary won gold in the President's Cup in Indonesia recently and Zareen won just silver in the Thailand Open. But deeper analysis shows that the field was much stronger in the Thailand tournament. Further, Mary Kom has only recently shifted to the 51kg category (her forte and the favourite class is the 48kg but she was forced to move up as it is no longer a part of the Olympics) while Zareen has always been in that class. A trail bout would have been the best way to settle the issue.

To be fair to the BFI, young pretenders have in the past won in trial bouts against more experienced pugilists only to perform disastrously in international competitions and had then faded away. A single bout is often not conclusive evidence of the superiority of a particular boxer. But if that is the way the selection process is designed, then it should have been followed. Also, Zareen is not your flash in the pan boxer but a consistent performer in her class. It was very unfair for the BFI to deny Zareen a chance to prove her mettle against the high profile Mary Kom. It also reinforced the view that star sportsperson in India often have their way when it comes to selection and associations often bend the rules to accommodate them.