oppn parties Gulberg Society Judgment: Gravity of Crime Ignored and Watered Down

News Snippets

  • Amit Panghal becomes first Indian male to win silver at the World Boxing Championships
  • "Gully Boy" to be India's entry for the Oscars
  • Rajeev Kumar called an "absconder" by the CBI
  • Alipore court refuses to grant anticipatory bail to Rajeev Kumar
  • Trump likely to sign a mini trade deal with India next week
  • Government planning a loan mela to cover 400 districts in two phases
  • PM Modi says Kashmiris need a hug from all Indians
  • NPA tag will not be put on any MSME till March 20
  • Government likely to announce another economic stimulus package today ahead of the GST Council meet in Goa
  • Air Marshall RKS Bhadauria, slated to retire just a few days from now, to be the next chief of IAF
  • PM Modi slams politicians from his own party who are making irresponsible statements on the Ayodhya case and tells them to wait for the Supreme Court order
  • Telecom panel says resident welfare associations (RWA) cannot give monopoly access to any one service provider and infrastructure in public spaces and residential complexes will have to be shared by all
  • Mamata Banerjee meets Amit Shah, tells him there is no need for an NRC in Bengal
  • After 14 days, there is no hope left for reviving Vikram, the moon lander
  • CBI teams search for elusive Rajeev Kumar
PM Modi to address more than 50000 people at the Howdy Modi event in Houston today where he will be joined by the US president Donald Trump
oppn parties
Gulberg Society Judgment: Gravity of Crime Ignored and Watered Down

By Sunil Garodia

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator. Writes for a number of publications.
After 14 long years, during which time a lot of things happened or were made to happen to tamper with the due process of justice, the Ahmedabad special court has finally found only 24 out of the 60 accused guilty of rioting and murder in the Gulberg Society case. It has handed out life imprisonment to 11 and milder sentence of seven year terms to the rest. It has ruled out the conspiracy theory and through its pronouncements in the order, sought to view the case as a ‘spontaneous’ expression of protest after the Godhra killings that took a turn for the worse after firing by Congress MP Ehsan Jafri.

This is a very simplistic and ultra lenient view not truly based on the way events played out at the Gulberg society that day. An armed mob had laid siege to the residential apartment block, baying for the blood of the inhabitants. Obviously, they had not come there to witness a qawali performance. Phone calls by residents to police were either not answered or not attended to. The judge thought that the crowd went mad after Jafri fired in self-defence. Since it is clear they had gathered there to take revenge on a particular community for the Godhra killings, it is wrong to assume that the shot Jafri fired made them do what they did to him after that.

Newspaper reports the next day chronicled the extreme hatred-driven-madness perpetrated by the mob at Gulberg society. They had stripped Jafri, broken and chopped off his fingers and limbs before throwing him in a fire alive. Even if it was not a conspiracy, it was a cold-blooded and beastly act that sought to punish an innocent person for alleged crimes committed by others, just because he belonged to the same community. Just for this, the perpetrators did not deserve a “second chance to reform and rehabilitate” which the court thought they did.

The chain of “they-did-this-to-us-so-we-should-do-this-to-them” can only be broken when culprits who instigate such revenge mongering are identified and handed out exemplary punishments mandated by law without taking a lenient view. Sadly, the court has missed out on the opportunity to tell lumpen elements and their backers, and the society at large, that law will not be an indulgent parent if hate crimes of such nature are committed.