oppn parties Majerhat Bridge Collapse: Same Old Story of Shamelessness

News Snippets

  • JNU students march against the steep hike in fees, keep HRD minister Ramesh Pokhriyal stuck at the venue of the convocation
  • USFDA says Cytotron, an anti-cancer kit developed by Bengaluru based Rajah Vijay Kumar, is a "breakthrough device" for treating liver, pancreatic and breast cancers
  • Car sales show a minuscule uptrend after declining continuously for 11 months
  • Industrial output contracts by 4.3% in September, the worst decline in 8 years
  • Centre defends abrogation of Article 370 in the Supreme Court, says the power under it was used by the President six times previously
  • Legendary singer Lata Mangeshkar admitted to hospital with lung infection, put on ventilator
  • Shiv Sena MP Arvind Sawant quits as Union Minister
  • National Security Advisor Ajit Doval met the leaders of both Hindus and Muslims in Delhi on Sunday to ensure peace and harmony is maintained after the Ayodhya verdict
  • Tipu Jayanti passes off peacefully in Karnataka
  • 10 dead as Cyclone Bulbul leaves destruction in its wake in West Bengal
  • Shefali Verma breaks Sachin's 30-year old record by scoring an international fifty at 15 years and 285 days
  • Former Chief Election Commissioner T N Seshan dies at 87
  • India beat Bangladesh by 30 runs to win the 3rd T20 and clinch the series 2-1. Deepak Chahar becomes the first Indian to take a hat-trick in T20s and returns the best bowling figures of 6/7
  • Centre removes SPG cover of the Gandhis. However, they will still get Z-category security
  • CJI Ranjan Gogoi will have a meeting with UP chief secretary and DGP of the state in his chamber ahead of the verdict on the Ayodhya land dispute next week
India Commentary wishes all its readers a very Happy Guruparab
oppn parties
Majerhat Bridge Collapse: Same Old Story of Shamelessness

By Sunil Garodia

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator. Writes for a number of publications.
It is not surprising that blame games have started after the collapse of Majerhat Bridge in Kolkata. Politicians and bureaucrats love to pass the buck and accidents are the best time to indulge in some fancy passing. It is important to know whether the collapse happened due to vibrations induced by the work being done by the railways nearby or due to the negligence of the state PWD. But what is definitely more important is to know why a bridge that was the lifeline of the city, connecting Behala, Thakurpukur, Joka, Amtala upto Diamond Harbour to the rest of the city, especially the port area in the city and across the river to Howrah and that spawned across major suburban railway lines was treated in such a cavalier manner by all agencies – state and Central.

Let us assume for a moment that the bridge collapsed due to vibrations from the pillaring being undertaken by the railways nearby. Was it not the duty of both the railways and the state PWD to make a fair assessment of the condition of the bridge before starting the work? Was it not required that supporting mild steel girders and pillars were placed under the sections of the bridge that were identified as weak and prone to collapse if vibrations occurred nearby? If railways conduct any work in a city, is it not the duty of the state PWD or the local corporation to ensure that they do not damage the existing infrastructure of the city? But on the face of it, the vibration theory does not wash as just two kilometers down the road is the old Behala area where centuries’ old private houses stand. The Metro railways have constructed more than 300 pillars on the Diamond Harbour Road without reports of any of the buildings collapsing. When the first Metro rail project was being carried out in Kolkata, numerous old buildings on the Chittaranjan Avenue were supported with garters and pillars to prevent an accident. Why was this not done in case of the Majerhat Bridge?

Then, major repair work on the bridge was long overdue. The structure carries a huge workload with a steady stream of trucks ferrying machinery or goods from the port area to the factories located in Amtala and Falta’s Special Economic Zone. Apart from that, a huge number of public transport and private vehicles use the bridge daily. Considering the load factor, the upkeep of the bridge was grossly neglected. During the recent monsoons, newspapers in Kolkata had highlighted the gaping potholes on the bridge that were causing severe distress to motorists and could have caused a major accident. Somewhere, somehow the rain had also played a part in further weakening and already weak structure. The state PWD cannot deny that it has been totally negligent in maintaining the bridge.

After the collapse, no patchwork will do. Since the bridge carries a huge load daily, the ideal response should be to raze the dilapidated structure completely and replace it with a new, modern and perhaps wider, bridge. The funds needed should be arranged, if need be with contribution from the railways and the city should be given a new and lasting asset to erase the horrific memory of the collapse. This is also an ideal time to carry out a detailed study of all bridges in the city and undertake comprehensive repair work wherever necessary.