By Linus Garg
First publised on 2026-11-19 02:36:31
The two-child penalty has outlived its purpose and should go. The national advertising of the small family has outlived its message and should be retired. Neither step justifies a lurch into pro-natalism. India needs a population policy that reads its own data, not one that repeats the slogans of 1990.
The premise has expired
When the Supreme Court upheld the disqualification of candidates with more than two children in Javed v. State of Haryana in 2003, India's total fertility rate stood at 3.02. The latest Sample Registration System report puts it at 1.9, below the replacement level of 2.1. A bench led by Justice P.S. Narasimha has now said that the fear of population explosion, which was the foundation of such laws, has dissipated. It has referred Javed to a larger bench.
The court has not yet overruled its 2003 judgment. It has told the country that the judgment rests on facts that no longer exist. A penal law whose factual basis has collapsed is difficult to defend as a reasonable restriction.
The legal case stands on its own
The demographic argument is only half the indictment. The penalty attaches to a private reproductive choice and lands on a citizen's right to hold office or earn a livelihood. The case before the court arose from the removal of Mangala Bhimrao Ingle as sarpanch of Kakoda gram panchayat for having more than two children. The bench noted that continuing such laws excludes an entire class of citizens from political representation, and it has flagged reproductive autonomy under Article 21.
There is also a question of who bears the penalty. Rules of this kind operate through a household, but their weight falls unevenly on women and on the poor, who have the least control over family size and the least capacity to fight a disqualification.
The penalty was never needed
Fertility fell without it. Rajasthan scrapped the limit for government employees in 2016 and Chhattisgarh in 2017. Madhya Pradesh withdrew it for government jobs in June 2026 after 23 years. That decision carries a flaw. It is not retrospective. Employees already dismissed under the rule will not be reinstated. A government that concedes the rule is wrong cannot fairly leave its past victims to carry it. Madhya Pradesh should revisit that.
The cost of a child already does the work
The question that matters is why families are small. The answer is cost. Education, healthcare and housing are expensive. Jobs are scarce. The gains of growth are spread across a large population. Couples have drawn their own conclusions and acted on them. Female education and child survival have reinforced the trend. The infant mortality rate is now 24 per 1,000 live births, and the fertility rate of literate women is 1.8 against 3.3 for illiterate women.
A penalty on top of this economic pressure is a second punishment for the same circumstances. Pro-natalist exhortation fails for the same reason. A couple that cannot afford a second child will not be moved by a slogan or a cash bonus of modest size.
The slogan belongs to another India
The small family message was written for a country with a fertility rate above three. Delhi now records 1.2. Kerala, Tamil Nadu and West Bengal record 1.3. The share of citizens aged 60 and above was 9.7 per cent in 2024 and may reach nearly 15 per cent by 2036. A government that keeps promoting smaller families in these states works against its own demographic interest.
The strongest counter-argument
India is not one demographic unit. Six states remain above replacement level: Bihar, Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, Chhattisgarh and Jharkhand. Bihar records 2.9. Critics argue that scrapping population measures in such states is counterproductive, and Assam still applies a two-child norm to jobs, welfare schemes and local elections.
The argument deserves a serious answer. The answer is that even in these states the levers that work are not punitive. Contraceptive access, girls' schooling and child survival moved the numbers elsewhere. Disqualification did not. States with the highest fertility are also the states where schools and clinics are weakest. Penalising a family for the state's failure to deliver those services is neither effective nor fair.
What the new Pew projections say, and what they do not
The Pew Research Center's projections released on 18 November have revived the demographic argument for family-size limits, and it must be met on the facts. Pew projects that the global Muslim population will grow by 80 per cent between 2020 and 2070, against 11 per cent for non-Muslims, and that Muslims will outnumber Christians by 2035. It puts the global Muslim fertility rate at 3.1 children per woman for 2020 to 2025, against 2.0 for non-Muslims.
These are global figures. Pew states that the high Muslim average is driven by sub-Saharan Africa, where the rate is 5.1. The 3.1 figure is not an Indian number and cannot be used as one. For India, Pew projects a Muslim population of 213 million in 2020 and 334 million in 2070. That is growth of about 57 per cent over fifty years, and India will rank second to Pakistan.
The projection also carries its own corrective. Pew's model assumes that fertility gaps between religious groups narrow toward convergence by 2100, as access to contraception and women's education improves. Its 2021 study of India found Muslim fertility falling from 4.4 children per woman in 1992 to 2.6 in 2015, while the gap with Hindus (2.1) halved from 1.1 to 0.5. Pew also warned that its projections are not predictions of everything that may happen.
A two-child penalty is the wrong answer to this concern. A rule that is neutral on paper but defended by pointing to one community's fertility would invite challenge under Articles 14 and 15. It would also punish individuals for a trend that is moving in every group without any penalty. Pew's own conclusion in 2021 was that religion alone does not determine how many children people have. Schooling, income and access to health services do.
What the government should do
1. Repeal all penalties linked to family size, including disqualification from local elections and denial of benefits, and make repeal apply to those already penalised.
2. Withdraw the blanket national small family campaign. Retain health messaging on spacing and maternal safety.
3. Concentrate voluntary measures, such as contraceptive access and girls' education, in the six states above replacement.
4. Begin planning for an older workforce: pensions, elder care, retraining and urban housing.
The state no longer has any business in a household's decision about how many children to raise. Its duty is to make the economy around the cradle affordable and secure. If it does that, family size will continue to settle at the level that families can sustain, and no penalty or advertisement will be required to get there.










