oppn parties Steve Smith: Fading Brain is Dangerous for Cricket

News Snippets

  • P V Sindhu assumes charge as Badminton World Federation council member after she was elected as chair of its Atheletes Commission in December 2025
  • Thomas Cup badminton: India beat Australia 5-0
  • Women's cricket: South Africa beat India by 3 runs in the 5th and final T20 to win the series 4-1
  • IPL: As pacers shine, Delhi just about avoid the lowest IPL total, manage to score 75, which RCB overtake in 6.3 overs losing just one wicket. Josh Hazlewood (4 for 12) and B Kumar (3 for 5) demolish DC
  • Isro plans to send civilians with STEM background to space
  • Government will consider giving law-making powers to local bodies in Ladakh
  • Supreme Court rules that a court can deny or cancel anticipatory bail but cannot direct an accused to surrender
  • Delhi police special cell cop, Neeraj Balhara, shoots and kills a delivery executive in Jafarpur Kalan area of NCR after an altercation. Another person was also injured in the shooting
  • Campaigning for the TMC in Bengal, Arvind Kejriwal asks whether the people of the state are 'terrorists' as the Centre has deployed over 2 lakh CAPF personnel for the polls
  • Campaining heats up in closing stages in the Bengal election with PM Modi leading the charge for the BJP and Mamata Banerjee replying ferociously for the TMC. Second phase polling is in Wednesday, 29th of April
  • Supreme Court panel sets minimum standards of staffing, equipment and infrastrcutre for hospitals having ICU facility
  • Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman says India's domestic consumption is the strongest shield against global shocks
  • Government is planning relief measures for airlines as the Gulf war shows no signs of ending soon
  • Women's cricket - 4th T20 versus South Africa: India win by 14 runs as Deepti Sharma turns in an allround show (39 not out and 5 for 19)
  • Sebastian Sawe of Kenya breaks the two-hour barrier in marathon, winning the London Marathon in 1 hour 59 minutes and 30 seconds
India signs a "once-in-a-generation" trade pact with New Zealand which aims to double bilateral trade to $5bn over the next five years
oppn parties
Steve Smith: Fading Brain is Dangerous for Cricket

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2017-03-08 13:11:14

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator. Author of Cyber Scams in India, Digital Arrest, The Money Trap and The Human Hack
When the Australian cricket team sledges, it is part of the game and anyone who takes umbrage is accused of being a crybaby. Aren’t adults capable of absorbing a few funny or pointed words without getting rattled? Isn’t it a test of temperament not to get disturbed by constant on-field chatter by players of the opposing team? These are the questions asked when the Australians are asked to shut up. But when the Indian players indulge in some sledging of their own, someone like Ian Healy ‘loses respect” for Indian captain Virat Kohli. How conceited can one be! Incidentally, Healy did not "lose' any respect for Steve Smith for seeking advice from the dressing room in a DRS moment, a thing that bordered on cheating. At least he has not said so till now.

Ian Healy was part of several Australian teams who were very aggressive and sledged opponents with fine tuned words and gestures. They played the game hard with the focus on winning at all costs, even if it meant by rubbing it in the wrong way. Other teams, either out of no confidence in their own abilities or difficulties with language, tried to either ignore their excesses or sportingly endure them. For some time, the West Indians gave them back as good as they got. Now, this Indian team believes in its capabilities and has a captain who is aggressive. So it is not going to take Australian barbs lying down. Healy is disturbed that the usual Australian tactic is not working this time. Hence, he is angry with Kohli.

But after the 2nd Test, it is clear that the Australians are crossing several lines. To look at the dressing room for advice on DRS is nothing short of cheating. Steve Smith did that not once but thrice as Kohli rightly pointed out in the press conference. From sledging to cheating is just a step forward for a team bent on winning at all costs. But the Australians need to remember that there are cameras everywhere now and even the smallest of gestures are captured on video. They cannot get away with such sleights. When Peter Handscomb takes the blame on himself by saying that it was he who advised Steve Smith to look at the box for DRS, it reflects very poorly on Smith. Handscomb might have been unaware of the rule that prohibits seeking advice from the dressing room but Smith as captain must have been aware of it. Why then did he listen to Handscomb? Steve Smith said he had a brain fade. At this rate, the Australians will have too many brain fades in the remaining two Test matches.

The fact of the matter is that now that the shoe is on the other leg, the Australians are behaving like crybabies.