oppn parties Sushma Swaraj: All Smoke and no Fire

News Snippets

  • Uttarakhand HC says marital discord, suspicion and quarrels cannot be held to be abetment of suicide
  • Two sisters, both brides-to-be, died by suspected suicide in Jodhpur. No suicide note was found
  • RTI reveals that 200 big cats were poached in India between 2005 and 2025, with the most in MP
  • After the US Supreme Court order on tariffs, Centre has put Indian trade team's US visit on hold
  • Delhi Police bust terror module linked to Lashkar that was plotting to strike in Delhi. Arrest 7 Bangladeshis with Aadhar IDs
  • PM Modi announced in his Mann Ki Baat that Edwin Lutyens' statue will be replaced with that of C Rajagopalchari at the Rashtrapati Bhawan
  • Facial recognition at Digi Yatra gates in Kolkata Airport suffered prolonged glitch on Sunday, forcing passengers to wait in long queues
  • Ranji Final: Strong Karnataka take on rising J&K in the match starting from Tuesday
  • Rising Stars women's cricket: India 'A' beat Bangladesh by 46 runs to capture title
  • Super 8s: Co-hosts Sri Lanka lose too, England beat them by 51 runs
  • Super 8s: South Africa crush India by 76 runs as nothing goes right for the hosts
  • PM Modi inaugurates India's fastest metro in Meerut and the first Vande Bharat sleeper in Bengal, This sleeper will cover Howrah to Guwahati route
  • After his consecutive failures, Abhishek Sharma has created a problem for the team management: should they give him one more chance in a vital match today or go for Sanju Samson as opener
  • A Pocso court in Prayagraj ordered an FIR against Swami Avi Mukteshawaranand and his disciple Muktanand Giri for molesting underage boys in their Magh Mela camp
  • TOI reported that while private universities filed more patents, elite institutions like IIT and IISc got more approvals between 2020-2025
T20 World Cup Super 8s: India get a reality check, outplayed by South Africa in their first match, end 12-match winning streak
oppn parties
Sushma Swaraj: All Smoke and no Fire

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2015-09-25 12:36:11

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator.
Everyone (that is everyone with a slant towards the BJP) is greatly impressed by Sushma Swaraj’s spirited (and it was just that, all smoke and no fire) defence of impropriety charges against her in Parliament. Lal Krishna Advani actually patted Swaraj after she finished the speech. Was that gesture the BJP old guard’s way of warning Modi to keep his hands off Swaraj? But was it actually a defence? To me, it seemed more like a tirade which asked: if you could do it, why can’t I? Swaraj forgot that two wrongs do not make a right. If Rajiv Gandhi was guilty of letting Warren Anderson run away and of taking kickbacks in the Bofors case through Quattrocchi, he was punished by the electorate for that. But how does that lessen or put a seal of propriety on what Swaraj did?

Or are we descending into an era when corruption will also take place on precedents set earlier. By that token, if Rs 100000 cr were lost by the exchequer in the 2G scam, should the NDA now make the nation lose Rs 200000 cr in a 4G scam? This is absurd, really. Is Sushma trying to say that what she did was right because leaders of the Congress had indulged in greater impropriety? Is she employing the mathematical formula that two minuses make a plus in politics?

Sushma Swaraj has to first make up her mind about whether she actually did anything to help Lalit Modi. For, at times she denies doing anything. Once she decides that she actually did something, she should care to inform the nation what she did. Then, she should go on to defend how what she did was not improper.

All the talk about Lalit Modi’s wife being sick or Rajiv Gandhi having done so and so or the advice to Rahul to study his family history is no defence at all. I, for one, am extremely disappointed how this issue has panned out, especially in the times of a Prime Minister who promises to give the nation a corruption-free government and whose massive victory was facilitated by voters disenchanted with the scam tainted UPA government.