oppn parties BSNL-MTNL Merger Will Work Only If Old Management Theories Are Junked

News Snippets

  • US House of Representative Foreign Affairs Committee chief, Elliot Engel, says "Chinese aggression" against India in Ladakh shows China is "willing to bully its neighbours"
  • Cyclone Nisagra expected to hit Mumbai with wind speeds of 100 kmph. The city placed on red alert
  • Monsoon hits Kerala, IMD says northern India too will get "good" rain
  • Moody's downgrades India's sovereign rating to Baa3, bringing it at par with other rating firms.
  • If the middle seat is used on flights, the passenger must be given a wrap-around cover in addition to mask and face shield, says the DGCA
  • The Union Cabinet approves many schemes for farmers, MSMEs and street vendors that were announced in the Covid-19 economic package
  • List of banned foreign items at Army canteens withdrawn after it was found that several Indian firms were also on the list
  • India and China seem to be headed for a longer stand-off at the border as the troops of both sides bring in heavy weaponry
  • The Centre has asked ISPs to block WeTransfer, which is now not available in India
  • Major shake-up in West Bengal BJP, those who switched to the party from the TMC given important posts
  • With 7573 new cases on Monday, India's total Covid-19 cases inch towards the 2-lakh mark
  • MSP of Kharif crops raised to increase the income of farmers
  • In a setback for aviation firms, jet fuel price has been increased by 48 percent
  • Terrorists strike on the outskirts of Srinagar, kill 2 BSF men
  • Alluding to the border dispute with India, Nepal PM says "Indian virus" is more dangerous than the Chinese or Italian virus
India Commentary wishes to all its readers a very Happy Id-Ul-Fitr
oppn parties
BSNL-MTNL Merger Will Work Only If Old Management Theories Are Junked

By Sunil Garodia

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator. Writes for a number of publications.

The government's decision to merge BSNL and MTNL clearly shows that it is aware that telecom is going to play a huge role in India's development since it is a great facilitator on which a host of economic activities and national security depend. It also shows that the government also recognizes that with rapid progress in emerging technologies in the sector, it cannot be left entirely in the hands of private players, especially since they would not be guided by the social good and might not serve areas where they do not see any profit.

On purely economic considerations, the merger is like throwing good money after bad. Both the PSUs have huge accumulated losses and are losing lots of money every month. They are heavily overstaffed, mismanaged and their marketing is based on stone-age principles. But in governance, economic considerations cannot be the sole criteria for taking decisions. The government has announced a liberal voluntary retirement package for employees above 50 years of age. That would eliminate a lot of deadwood from the two entities. But would that be enough?

The telecom sector is hugely competitive and needs massive and regular funds. Although the merged entity would be blessed with an infrastructure that no private player can match, it also needs to be stated that even private players with deep pockets are losing money. Even as this is being written, it has been reported that after the Supreme Court ruling on adjusted gross revenue, just Airtel and Vodafone-Idea would have to pay the government a total of Rs 50k cr out of the total of Rs 92k cr payable by the telecom companies.

If the government is serious about reviving the merged entity, voluntarily retiring senior employees will not be enough. It will have to change the way the entity will work. It will have to bring in fresh talent, if possible from the private sector and completely junk the current marketing policies. It will have to think of a name for the entity that appeals to the younger generation. It will have to invest in research and adopt cutting-edge technology before the private players. It will have to show the customers that it is not a sloth-filled and careless PSU but a competitive, new-age entity that can match and even overtake private players in providing the best services.