oppn parties Chaos, Clashes And Total Mismanagement As Migrants Return Home

News Snippets

  • Supreme Court dismisses industry bodies' plea to stop the SBI from disclosing the numbers of the electoral bonds
  • NDA finalizes seat sharing in Bihar - BJP 17, JD(U) 16 aqnd LJP 5
  • Election Commission removes Home secretaries of Gujarat, UP, Bihar, HP, Uttarakhand and Jharkhand and the DGP of Bengal
  • Telangana governor Tamilsai Soundararajan resigned from his post and is likely to contest for the BJP from Chennai
  • ED claims K Kavitha of the BRS paid Kejriwal and Sisodia Rs 100cr in the alleged liquor scam in Delhi. AAP says this is a ploy to malign their names
  • Supreme Court tells SBI not to be selective and disclose full details of electoral bonds
  • With the US Department of Justice rpobing bribery charges against Adani group companies, Adani group shares and bonds are under pressure
  • Narayan Murthy gifts Infosys shares worth Rs 240cr to his 4-month-old grandson
  • Tata Sons to sell Rs 9362cr worth shares of TCS to pare debt
  • Stocks were positive on Monday - Sesex climbed 104 points to 72748 and Nifty 32 points to 22055
  • IOA dissolves the ad-hoc panel and gives full control of WFI to elected panel headed by Brij Bhushan aide Sanjay Singh
  • Controversy erupts after BJP leader Tathagata Roy prescribes the cicumcision test for those seeking citizenship under CAA. TMC calls it a 'vulgar jibe'
  • Rahul Gandhi concludes his Bharat Jodo Nyay Yatra in Mumbai, holds a mega rally at Shivaji Park and says the BJP does not have the courage to change the Constitution despite making a lot of noise in that regard
  • ED issues two fresh summons to Delhi CM Arvind Kejriwal in the liqour excise case just a day after he got bail in the earlier cases of ignoring the summons
  • A 14-year-old girl killed herself after she was strip-searched at school in Bagalkot in Karnataka
Election Commission orders removal of home secretaries of 6 states and the DGP of Bengal
oppn parties
Chaos, Clashes And Total Mismanagement As Migrants Return Home

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2020-05-05 11:43:32

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator.

Total mismanagement over sending back migrant workers has resulted in clashes breaking out at many places while discontent has increased in several other places. Police clashed with violent workers in Surat and Bengaluru while the administration had a tough time controlling the large number of migrants who assembled at places like Ahmedabad.

It was announced in the press conference that migrant workers would need to register for being eligible to board trains. The same was reported in the media. But the administration should also have informed the migrants about it. It was not very difficult to do that as almost all cities and towns have migrant colonies or areas where a large number of such workers reside. Announcements could have been made over loudspeakers mounted on vehicles or camps for registration could have been set up in such areas. But since nothing was done, it was natural for the workers to get agitated.

Then, a needless controversy arose over the charging of the ticket price from the workers. The Centre now claims that it is paying 85% of the fare and has asked the states to contribute the rest. It should have stated this in the press conference to announce the running of the trains. Since nothing was clear on this account, the opposition parties are politicizing the issue. The Congress has said that it will pay the fare while the trustees of the Dargah at Ajmer are claiming to have paid for thousands of migrants. How is it possible if the government is not charging the fare from them?

Another issue is that a large number of workers are being found to be corona positive when they are being tested on reaching their home states. This proves that the health protocol of just screening them while boarding the trains or buses is not enough. At this rate, these returning workers will spread the virus all over the country, resulting in a huge fresh wave of infection and possible community transmission. The government has to take stricter measures to ensure they are not carriers by prescribing random tests for registered migrants before they board the trains.

The issue of stranded migrants and the problems being faced by them was the subject matter of endless debate for the last 40 days. The government knew that it would have to make arrangements for sending them back. Hence, it should have planned every detail before making the announcement. Further, it should have publicized all decisions at that time to avoid confusion and mismanagement. The way things are panning out, it is certain that there will be more clashes and there are chances that the situation will go out of control in some places. The government needs to streamline things at the earliest to avoid that.