oppn parties ED: Integrity & Independence At Stake If Extensions Given To Incumbent Chief

News Snippets

  • Coal exploration plan worth Rs 2980cr cleared by Union cabinet
  • Government ploughs in Rs 89000cr in BSNL for 4G, 5G spectrum operations
  • Stocks gain on Wednesday: Sensex adds 350 points to 63142 and Nifty 127 points to 18726
  • Wresters agitation: Sports minister assures action by June 15, wrestlers put off agitation till then
  • WTC Final: India lose the plot after putting Australia to bat as Steve Smith stands like a rock and Travis Head counter attacks to put Australia (327 for 3) in command on the first day
  • Wrestlers agitation: Bajrang Punia. Sakshi Mallik and Vinesh Phogat rejoin work in Railways, BKU pulls back but wrestlers say agitation will go on
  • UP bahubali-turned-politician gets life in 32-year-old murder case
  • India-US seal defence cooperation roadmap as Defence minister Rajnath Singh meets US Defence Secretary Lloyd Austin
  • CBI probe in the train mishap will look at error in interlocking system and probe the sabotage angle
  • Violence continues in Manipur as three persons were killed after a mob attacked an ambulance in Imphal West district
  • Karnataka cabinet is likely to discuss cow slaugther law in its next meeting
  • Rahul Gandhi woos diaspora in the US, tries to show the fight in India as between those who believe in Mahatma Gandhi and those in Nathuram Godse
  • In preparation of a shutdown, MTNL moving operations to BSNL
  • Services sector sustains growth although Services PMI slips from 62 in April to 61.2 in May
  • Stocks gain handsomely on Monday: Sensex rises 240 points to 62787 and Nifty 59 points to 18593
WTC Final: Australia take firm grip on Day1 - Travis Head (146 batting) and Steve Smith (95 batting) take them to 327 for 3 as Indian bowling falters
oppn parties
ED: Integrity & Independence At Stake If Extensions Given To Incumbent Chief

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2023-03-24 07:45:50

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator.

The Supreme Court is looking into the process through which the government grants extensions to the chief of the Enforcement Directorate. In a decision in 2021, the court had directed the Centre that the existing laws mandated that extensions to ED chiefs be given on rare occasions and had specifically asked it not to extend the tenure of the then ED chief Sanjay Mishra. But the government, in order to neutralize the SC ruling, brought in the CVC (Amendment) Act, 2021, the DSPE (Amendment) Act, 2021 and the Fundamental (Amendement) Rules, 2021 and armed itself with powers to grant extension.

The Supreme Court had appointed senior advocate K V Vishwanathan as amicus curiae to assist it in this regard. Vishwanathan was assisted by advocate Ravi Raghunath. Now the amicus curiae has told the Supreme Court that going by several past Supreme Court judgments regarding the independence of investigating agencies and the fact that the amendments were violative of Article 14 as they were discriminatory and/or arbitrary, in his opinion the said amendments were illegal  and would compromise the independence and integrity of ED.

There is no doubt that the amendments were brought in only to neutralize the SC order. The very fact that post the amendments, the government can give five extensions of one year each to the incumbent means that the government can keep its favourite officer as ED chief for 7 years (initial appointment for 2 years which can be extended piecemeal for another five years). This would have serious implications for the independence and integrity of the agency. The excuse that the incumbent needs to be granted an extension so that running investigations under him can be closed is specious - there are other capable officers who can successfully close them if elevated to the post. The government must realize that such extended terms are double-edged swords and will be used by other political parties to keep their favourite officers in place when they come to power. The best way would be to increase the initial term to three years with no further extension and decide on the appointment of the next chief well in advance so that the transfer is smooth and the post does not remain vacant even for a day.