oppn parties Increase Judicial Infrastructure, Fill Vacancies and Stop Frivolous Adjournments To Clear Pendency

News Snippets

  • PM Modi says that if Congress is voted to power in Haryana, the state will face the same financial problems that Himachal is facing under the party's rule
  • Competition Commission of India has said that smartphone majors are colluding with e-commerce firms to exclusively launch products on their platforms in alleged breach of anti-trust laws
  • Supreme Court rules that delay in claiming compensation for land acquisition by the government is no excuse to deny it as it is the duty of the government to pay the compensation.
  • PM Modi said that terrorism was breathing its last in J&K
  • Conbgress has alleged that Sebi chief Madhabi Buch traded in listed securities and invested in China-focused funds during her tnure at the agency
  • India to sing $4bn Predator drone deal with US
  • Union Minister Nitin Gadkari has disclosed that the opposition parties backed him as Prime Minister in place of Narendra Modi but he refused.
  • Noted economist Ajit Ranade removed as VC of Gokhale Institute of Politics & Economics in Pune due to not fulfilling eligibility criteria related to teaching experience
  • Chess Olympiad: Arjun Erigaisi wins his fourth consecutive game
  • Asian Champions Trophy hockey- India beat Pakistan 2-1 in a tough match to remain unbeaten in the group stage. They will meet Korea in the semifinals
  • Davis Cup: S Balaji and R Ramanathan lose, India 0-2 down on first day
  • Delhi Police arrested Sangram Dass, said to be the kingpin of an inter-state new-born baby tafficking racket, from Kolkata after a 1500-km chase
  • NC leader Omar Abdullah alleged that the B|JP was forging secret deals with some regional parties and independents to form the government in J&K
  • Rajasthan Police has devised a Standard Operating Procedure (SOP), as directed by the Rajasthan HC, to help married and live-in couples facing threats from families and others. It icludes helplines and safe houses
  • A 3-storey building collapsed in the busy Transport Nager area in Lucknow killing 8 and injuring 28 others
Junior doctors do not agree to meet Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee without live-streaming of meeting /////// CBI arrests ex-principal of R G Kar College Sandip Ghosh and OC of Tala PS in Kolkata, Abhijit Mondal' for destrcution of evidence in the rape-murder case
oppn parties
Increase Judicial Infrastructure, Fill Vacancies and Stop Frivolous Adjournments To Clear Pendency

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2022-05-02 03:52:01

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator.

After six years, the conference of Central and state leadership and top judges was held in New Delhi on Saturday, April 30, 2022. Speaking on the occasion, CJI N V Ramana said that non-performance by the executive, poorly drafted laws by the legislature and alarmingly low number of judges which stand at just 20 per million people, were the main reasons behind the huge backlog of cases. While these are valid reasons for much of litigation, they are not the only reasons for pendency.

Justice Ramana said that "if tehsildars acted on farmers' grievances, if the panchayats and civic bodies discharged their duties, if the revenue authorities acquired land following due process, if service laws were applied fairly and if police investigations were fair and no illegal arrests made, majority of the cases would not come before the courts". He added that "of the legislature passes a law, with clarity of thought, foresight and with people's welfare in mind, the scope of litigation is minimized".

While these are valid points and the executive and the bureaucracy must act with efficiency, diligence and fairness by adhering to the letter and the spirit of the law at all times to prevent litigation, is it also not a fact that whenever executive action is taken, the party against whom or in whose favour such action is taken finds some fault with the action and approaches the courts for redress? For instance, even when someone is awarded compensation, they think it is too low and file a case to get an enhanced amount. Is it also not a fact that however well a law is drafted, there are litigants and lawyers who will challenge its provisions in a court of law? No law can be foolproof and every law is interpreted by litigants and lawyers as per their reading and they approach the courts to get the correct judicial reading.

Hence, if cases will come to court even if the executive acts fairly and even if laws are enacted after due debate and discussion, what is needed is to find out ways to how to deliver speedy justice and avoid pendency. Thus, the third point made by CJI N V Ramana is most important. If India has just 20 judges per million people, it cannot hope not to have pendency of cases, especially when both the government and the people have a tendency to rush to the courts even for small matters. The Centre and the states agreed at the conference to increase judicial infrastructure and establish a national judicial infrastructure development authority with state units in which the chief justices and chief ministers of respective states would be members. This is a good development and should be fast-tracked.

The need is to set up more courts, increase the number of judges, fill vacancies in a planned manner and dispose of cases fast by not allowing too many adjournments. In an editorial, The Times of India has suggested that the retirement age of judges in the Supreme Court and the High Courts should be raised to 70. This is a good suggestion and the government can look into it as it would increase productivity. The matter of appointment and transfer of judges should also be revisited (after the scuttling of the NJAC) and the executive and the judiciary must agree upon a formula which results in a smooth process of such appointments and transfers. The main thing is that the process should be so strong that there should be no vacancies in high courts and the Supreme Court at any time.