oppn parties Justice Gogoi: Brazening It Out

News Snippets

  • Citizenship Bill to be tabled in the Lok Sabha today. Heated debate likely
  • Domestic tourism in Kashmir slumps by 87% in August-November period
  • Prime Minister Modi says police must make women feel safe
  • West Indies beat India by 8 wickets in the second T20 at Thiruvananthpuram
  • Rahul Gandhi says the NDA government kept Chidambaram in jail for so many days in order to take revenge
  • Kohli reclaims the top spot in ICC rankings from Steve Smith
  • Cabinet clears the Citizenship Bill. It will be placed in the Lok Sabha in a day or two
  • Hindu Jagran Manch members clash with the police in Kolkata after being refused permission to take out a rally
  • West Bengal Governor Jagdeep Dhankar says important files were sent late to him and his delay in signing them draws criticism from the TMC. It also brings the state assembly to a halt
  • 92,000 BSNL & MTNL employees apply for early retirement taking advantage of the new government offer. It will result in an annual savings of Rs 8.700 cr for the merged entity
  • Dengue deaths multiply in Kolkata even as the CM, Mamata Banerjee, asks the opposition not to politicize the matter
  • Government orders inquiry into the breach of security at Priyanka Vadra's house
  • Chennai-based engineer Shanmuga Subramanian helps Nasa find the pieces of Vikram lander on the Moon's surface
  • New Maharashtra CM Uddhav Thackeray says his administration will take back cases against Dalits and activists in the Bhima Koregaon case
  • Dhawan calls his dismissal "nonsense"
43 killed in a fire at units in illegal building in heart of Delhi
oppn parties
Justice Gogoi: Brazening It Out

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2019-04-21 20:05:46

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator. Writes for a number of publications.
There are two sacred principles in public life: one should not only be pure but also appear to be so and one should avoid conflict of interest. One more principle is there in the legal field: one must never be a judge in his own cause.

When charges of sexual harassment were leveled against CJI Ranjan Gogoi, he ceased to appear pure. Obviously, he is innocent till proved guilty of the charges, but the very fact that he occupies the highest judicial post in the country, it is required that he disassociates himself from all duties till the matter is resolved. Just raising the bogey of the independence of the judiciary being in peril is not going to help. The case needs to be taken to its logical conclusion and Justice Gogoi’s presence in the Supreme Court, even though he will obviously not hear the case, is not proper.

Then, bypassing all norms of propriety, the CJI constituted a special bench which included him, dealing a severe blow to avoiding conflict of interest. He recused himself after making opening remarks and did not sign the order passed (which was another first, as only the other two judges signed the order).

The Women in Criminal Law Association have issued a statement which states that “the legal institutional response to such a complaint as mandated under the “In-House Procedure” applicable to Judges of the Supreme Court and the High Court, along with the Sexual Harassment of Women at the Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal Act) Act, (“POSH Act”) read with the Supreme Court Sexual Harassment Regulations, 2013, is for the designated inquiry committee to take cognizance of the complaint, constitute an inquiry committee and give notice to the respondent as to the initiation of such proceedings.” This was not followed.

When #MeToo allegations were made against Union minister MJ Akbar and many other public figures, mainly from the film industry, there were strong repercussions. Public pressure forced the minister to resign. Accused from other fields were isolated with some people even refusing to work with them. Remember, all this was before they were proven guilty, just to uphold the purity principle.

If MJ Akbar, Alok Nath and others are exonerated by the courts, they will be vindicated and will be welcomed back in their respective fields. Those who made the allegations will be suitably punished as per law. But till then, they have to be away from power, from anything through which they can influence the case against them.

The same goes for Justice Ranjan Gogoi. In fact, being the Chief Justice of India, it is all the more important that he stays far removed from the legal process that will now unfold to verify the charges leveled against him. The country is waiting with expectation to see what the judiciary does when faced with the dilemma of one of its own being charged with such serious impropriety. More than the independence of the judiciary is at stake and not in the way Justice Gogoi means it.