oppn parties Opposition Will Not Gain By Uncivilzed Behavior

News Snippets

  • Formed Indian cricket captain Kapil Dev suffers a heart attack, undergoes angioplasty and is now stable
  • With prices rising abnormally, the Centre has put a limit on the stock of onions under the Essential Commodities Act
  • India bans many imported goods in Army canteens
  • India tells Pakistan that any talks with it will not have J&K on the agenda
  • Prime Minister Modi says there will be no reconsideration of abrogation of Article 370 and the Farm Bills
  • Pakistan will remain on FATF grey list till February
  • The US says it is working to ensure that the standoff between India and China does not escalate further
  • Tejasvi Yadav says Lalu will be released on November 9 and Nitish will get his farewell on 10th
  • Mumbai Indians beat Chennai Super Kings by 10 wickets to move to the top of the table
  • Massive power outage brings Mumbai to a halt, local train services disrupted. Power restored in some areas by late evening
  • Andhra HC takes cognizance of objectionable posts against judges on social media, orders a CBI inquiry
  • Hathras victim's family asks Allahabad High court to shift the case out of UP
  • PM Modi says government spending will boost demand and hasten economic recovery
  • Centre to spend Rs 37000 crore to boost demand, will give loans and advances to Central staff and will spend Rs 25000 crore on infra projects while states will get Rs 12000 crore to spend on capital projects
  • No consensus in the GST Council meeting, states to borrow to meet shortfall, allowed to float bonds
Mehbooba Mufti says "dacoits" have taken away the flag of J&K and adds that she will not unfurl the Indian flag until the right to unfurl the J&K flag is restored
oppn parties
Opposition Will Not Gain By Uncivilzed Behavior

By A Special Correspondent
First publised on 2020-09-21 11:14:15

Among the two generally used systems of voting on bills in parliament are voice vote and division, or electronic voting. While voice vote is used as a matter of preference, electronic voting is used in matters of importance or when there is a demand. But there are certain rules for conducting an electronic poll and the main requirement is that the lobbies must be clear and all members must be seated with discipline in their seats. The Opposition parties created an unruly situation yesterday when the farm bills were being put to vote in the Rajya Sabha and that did not help their cause.

Perhaps it was never their intention to have electronic voting. They knew that the government had the numbers. They also knew that if they provoked the deputy chairman enough, he would go by voice vote and they could then say that their demands were not met. There can be no other explanation for the way the opposition MPs behaved and tried to stop the house proceedings in a shameful manner. They climbed the table, threw the rule book and other papers and tore off the microphone in scenes resembling happenings at a gangster meet gone awry. That this has become par for the course in Indian parliament is disgusting.

If the opposition MPs had behaved as the deputy chairman wanted them to, perhaps their demand to conduct a division vote for sending the bills to a select house committee for deliberations before putting them up for voting would have been met. But by not allowing order to be restored for conducting the electronic voting, they forced the deputy chairman to call for a voice vote. The deputy chairman had not acceded to their earlier demand, made as per convention, that the voting be deferred till Monday as the scheduled working time of the house for the day had been consumed by extending the time.

The Congress later said that since the house was being held hostage, the opposition had to resort to raising their voice. But what is achieved by behaving in such fashion? Other than delaying the passage of the bills and making a spectacle of themselves, the opposition MPs achieved nothing. Instead, they could have coordinated among themselves and could have registered their protest in a more civilized manner through informed debate and discussion. But their frustration, borne out of their lack of numbers, made them behave in a manner that neither helped them nor the farmers.