oppn parties Pre-natal Sex Determination: Maneka Gandhi Has it Wrong

News Snippets

  • Amit Shah says the government will identify and deport illegal immigrants from all parts of the country
  • Reports from Pakistan confirm that Hafiz Saeed has been arrested and sent to jail
  • After the SC order, Karnataka Speaker says he will go by the Constitution in deciding on the resignations of the 16 MLAs
  • Rebel MLAs say they will not attend the trust vote on Thursday
  • Supreme Court rules that rebel MLAs cannot be forced to attend the assembly and vote in the floor test
  • Both the Centre and the Assam government have sought re-verification of up to 20% of draft NRC data
  • Pakistan opens its airspace for Indian planes
  • Dilapidated building collapses in Mumbai, killing more than 10 people while many were still trapped
  • Kulbhushan Jadhav case verdict to be delivered today by the ICJ
  • A Vistara flight landed in Lucknow with just 5 to 10 minutes of fuel left in the tank
  • Supreme Court to decide on Karnataka MLAs plea today
  • Karnataka alliance to face floor test on Thursday
  • China says that the next Dalai Lama will be appointed by it
  • Pakistan assures India that no anti-India activity would be allowed in the Kartarpur corridor
  • Pakistan to allow visa-free access to 5000 pilgrims every day to undertake pilgrimage using the Kartarpur corridor
ISRO calls-off Chandrayaan-2 mission launch at last moment due to technical snags. revised date will be announced later
oppn parties
Pre-natal Sex Determination: Maneka Gandhi Has it Wrong

By Sunil Garodia

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator. Writes for a number of publications.
Radical & impractical idea

Sanjay Gandhi had introduced India to government sponsored forced sterilization, or nasbandi, during the Emergency. It was a radical and impractical idea that sought to control the country’s burgeoning population. But the very fact that it was coercive, undertaken during a totalitarian regime without debate and discussion and mainly directed at one particular community meant that it was despised and doomed to failure. Now his widow Maneka Gandhi, in another equally radical and impractical idea, wants India to adopt mandatory and institutionalized sex determination tests and ban the delivery of children at home to prevent female foeticide.

Sex tests are not the need of the hour

There is no doubt that female foeticide poses a real danger to India. In every Census, we find that lesser girls are born. The 2011 Census puts the child birth ratio at 919 girls for every 1000 boys, which is alarming. But having mandatory sex determination tests is even more alarming. First of all, it will entail an additional expenditure for the parents-to-be. Which test will be mandatory – ultrasound, CVC, or amniocentesis? While USG is relatively cheap and done periodically during pregnancy to see if the child is developing properly, the other two tests cost anywhere between Rs 15000 to Rs 30000 or more. Who is going to bear this cost? Secondly, these tests are not done everywhere. Third, even if the test is done, how will the government ensure that if a female foetus is found, it will not be subsequently aborted? The government does not have the kind of policing infrastructure required to prevent this. It is unable to prevent illegal sex determination tests, which are few in numbers compared to the abortions that might take place once the sex of the child is officially known. As most of these tests can determine the sex of the child only in fairly advanced stages of pregnancy, the need is to police abortion clinics to prevent such life threatening abortions. The need is to police the birth of ‘designer’ babies through Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis (PGD) by which would-be parents who take the route of artificial reproduction, often ‘get’ a boy child.

Are there enough hospitals?

As for the second idea that delivery of children at home should be banned, there is just one reason why it should not be. Are there enough hospitals in India to cater to the number of pregnancies that occur every year? The answer, obviously, is no. Then where will the women who do not find hospitals give birth? The need of the hour is to have more educated intermediaries who can assist in child birth at home in rural and semi-urban areas. The need is to educate parents-to-be about hygiene and safe practices.

Educate people, encourage girls

There has been a shift in attitude towards the girl child in the last few years. The government, especially PM Modi, has contributed towards this by starting several girl-specific schemes. With his drive to have separate toilets for girls in schools, hopefully the dropping out rate for girls will decline and they will have better education too. Parents, too, have realized that with changing social mores, there is no difference between a girl and a boy. The old notions of a boy carrying forward the family tree etc. hold no meaning in this nuclear family age. Gone are the days when family pressure would force people to try for a boy even if they already had two or three girls. Apart from some states like Punjab, Haryana, Rajasthan and western UP, parents now wish to provide good education and proper health and nutrition to just a couple of children, irrespective of whether they are boys or girls. After all, do we not get a son – in the form of a son-in-law – when the daughter is married?