oppn parties Safoora Zargar Case: Granting Bail Is Not Charity But A Right Of The Unconvicted

News Snippets

  • University vice-chancellors in West Bengal decide not to hold final-year examinations despite UGC prod, will instead go by the state government advised 80-20 formula where 80% will be marked on performance in past semesters and 20% on internal assessments in the final semester
  • The Centre wants the ITI and other top Indian firms to bid for 5G as Chinese firms Huawei and ZTE are not likely to be allowed to participate
  • India and China agree on total disengagement to return to peace ahead of the next round of military talks
  • The Supreme Court allows delivery of summons and notices via WhatsApp and email, but questions remain on proof of actual receipt
  • National Investigation Agency says the proceeds from the Kerala gold smuggling case could have been used for terrorist activities
  • Four Maoists shot dead in Valmiki Tiger Reserve in Bihar
  • Despite localized lockdown, Covid cases continue to rise at an alarming rate in West Bengal. Newer areas brought under containment zones in Kolkata
  • ICSE, ISC results declared, Average scores in the English paper, 20% lower this year than the average in most years, pulls down the aggregate for most candidates
  • IIP contracts by 35% in May. Manufacturing goes down by 39.3%
  • Row erupts over CBSE's decision to reduce the syllabus by 30% this academic year due to the disruption caused by the pandemic. Experts say several lessons that the ruling dispensation does not like are being removed
  • Gangster Vikas Dubey's nephew killed in an encounter by UP police who also pick up his key aide Raju Khullar and his son Adarsh
  • MHA sets up an inter-ministerial committee to probe the alleged financial misdeeds of three trusts linked to the Gandhi family
  • Actor Jagdeep, most famous for his Soorma Bhopali act in Sholay, passes away
  • Pakistan says Kulbhushan Jadhav has declined to file a review petition and will stick to his mercy plea. India calls it a farce
  • India to keep a strict vigil to confirm that the Chinese are abiding by the deal on the pullback at the LAC
Amitabh Bachchan and his son Abhishek admitted to hospital for coronavirus
oppn parties
Safoora Zargar Case: Granting Bail Is Not Charity But A Right Of The Unconvicted

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2020-06-25 16:07:05

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator. Writes for a number of publications.

Safoora Zargar, a student of Jamia Millia Islamia University was arrested for her alleged role in the Delhi riots. She was charged under the draconian UAPA. She was twice denied bail by the Sessions Court. The Sessions Court took the erroneous plea that bail was denied because of section 43-D(5) of the UAPA. But the section does not put a bar on bail. It just says that bail cannot be granted for any accused under UAPA until the Public Prosecutor has been heard regarding his or her objections to the bail application and that too for activities under Chapter IV and VI of the act which specify "terrorist acts" and "membership of terrorist organizations". After hearing the objections of the prosecution, it is upon the judge to apply his mind and decide on bail. But Safoora was charged for unlawful activity which does not fall under any of the two chapters. Hence, section 43-D(5) did not apply in her case. The Supreme Court finally granted bail to her on "humanitarian grounds" as she is pregnant.

Bail, not jail has been the golden rule on which the Indian judiciary decides bail applications. This rule was first made famous by the eminent jurist Justice Krishna Iyer in the case State of Rajasthan vs Balchand where he wrote that "the basic rule may perhaps be tersely put as bail, not jail". It is a clearly set precedent from various Supreme Court cases that barring exceptional cases, bail must be granted to the accused in most cases. Yet, Safoora had to invoke her pregnancy and apply for bail on humanitarian grounds. The scope of the fundamental right to liberty granted under Article 21 of the Indian Constitution includes bail as it is the right of any person to have freedom unless he or she is proven guilty of a crime by a court or unless the law under which he or she is arrested specifically bars the grant of bail. This was ignored in Safoora's case and she was incarcerated for two months as a suspect as if she was not a student but a hardened terrorist, freeing whom on bail would be dangerous.