oppn parties Sakshi Maharaj: Inflammatory Comments

News Snippets

  • Supreme Court rules that functional disability should be the deciding factor in granting road accident damages and not any doctor-issued disability certificate
  • Supreme Court flagged the fact that nearly 56% of the vehicles plying in India were uninsured and asked the government to challan them
  • An Air India flight from Phuket to Delhi encountered severe turbulence and 17 passengers were admitted to hospital with injuries
  • Calcutta HC said that heavens won't fall if Vande Matram is made mandatory to sing in madrasas
  • Kolkata Municipal Corporation has sought government nod for increasing city's wards to 200+ to keep residents in each ward between 16000 to 18000
  • Government has said that partially filled online Census forms may be allowed
  • Government may allow fees on UPI payments above Rs 2000, except on transfer between two individuals
  • Brent crude falls below $80 per barrel
  • Government has increased the LIC offer for sale to Rs 31,400cr with an additional 4% on the block
  • Stock markets become nervous on Tuesday due to Gulf situation: Sensex slides 210 points and Nifty sheds 159 points ahead of RBI MPC meets today
  • Indian cricket team lands in Sri Lanka for a 2-Test series
  • A former French Navy pilot who had alleged that IAF had lost Rafales during Operation Sindoor has been held in France on spying charges
  • An ordinary zari worked living just 100km away from Kolkata was stunned to find Rs 100cr deposited in the bank account. The bank has frozen her account pending enquiry
  • Businessmen in Kolkata gets a Rs 5-crore extortion call, allegedly from the Lawrence Bishnoi gang
  • NTA floats tenders to secure offices and exam materials round-the-clock
Tarun Tejpal, former editor of Tehelka, was sentenced to 10 years in jail by Bombay HC for raping a colleague. This judgment overturns the acquittal by a Goa sessions court
oppn parties
Sakshi Maharaj: Inflammatory Comments

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2017-01-07 19:24:04

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator. Author of Cyber Scams in India, Digital Arrest, The Money Trap and The Human Hack
Sakshi Maharaj is back to spewing venom on Muslims through unsubstantiated charges. His comments that 4 wives, 40 children and three divorces is causing population explosion in the Muslim community is in extreme bad taste, highly inflammatory and not backed by facts – from the Census data and other studies. Although the BJP has distanced himself from his comments, there should be another way to punish the lawmaker for his frequent outbursts.

First of all, if Sakshi Maharaj does not know, there is something called the sex ratio in population figures. The all-India male-female ratio stands at 1000:943 as per the 2011 Census. The ratio for Muslims is 1000:951. So, if there are only 951 females for every 1000 males in the Muslim community, how can every male marry four times? There simply are not so many women for all Muslim men to have four wives.Also, if one Muslim male marries four times, three others are going to remain unmarried as there would be no brides for them.

Secondly, let us take the increase in number of Muslims. Between the 2001 and 2011 Censuses, the Muslim population rose marginally, from being 13.4% of the population to being 14.2%. It is another matter that the Hindu population declined marginally during the same period, from 80.5% to 79.8 percent. In absolute terms, Hindus added 13.9 crore to the population while Muslims accounted for 3.4 crore. This does not support the charge that Muslim couples are giving birth to 40 children.

Thirdly, the fertility rate among the Muslims also does not support the charge of 40 children being borne by every couple. In fact, the fertility rate among the Muslims declined from 4.1 in 2001 to 3.2 in 2010. The National Family Health Survey (NFHS) shows that fertility rate is declining faster among the Muslims than Hindus. In this age, every parent is concerned to bring up his or her child in the best possible manner and that costs good money. No couple bears more children than their income can support. Hence, fertility rates in India are coming down across the board.

Lastly, what is it about three divorces? How can a divorce, even one divorce, have any bearing on the number of children one raises? Sakshi Maharaj just has to say something against the Muslims to prove his staunch Hindu credentials and this should not be tolerated any more. If one is a Hindu sanyasi, instead of poking one’s nose like an uneducated buffoon without knowing facts into another community’s affairs, one should concentrate on using the knowledge one has gleaned from the study of the Hindu granths (if one has gleaned any, that is) and try and rid the Hindu society of the various ills that are plaguing it.

Sakshi Maharaj is doing a great disservice to the nation by spreading rumours. The BJP should ask him not to make baseless and unsubstantiated charges against the Muslim community. If a nation where 80 percent of the population is Hindu still has fears of being swamped by Muslims, there is something seriously wrong with opinion makers in the Hindu community. The best way forward for all Indians is to study facts and not be swayed by such inflammatory comments from the supposed protectors of the Hindu faith.