oppn parties The Modi Government: Right In Being Firm On CAA, Wrong In Stifling Protests By Force

News Snippets

  • For the first time ever, Mukesh Ambani buys a 29% stake in Gautam Adani's Mahan Energen, a subsidiary of Adani Power to source 500MW of electricity from the company's power plant in MP
  • Stocks continue to rise on Thursday - Sensex gains 639 points to 73635 and Nifty 203 points to 22326
  • Golf - Indian Open: 3 Indians at tied 14th as Joost Luiten takes the lead with a wonderful 7-under 65
  • IPL: RR beat DC by 12 runs as Riyan Parag (84 off just 45 balls) shines
  • SP drops two candidates owing allegiance to Azam Khan from Rampur and Moradabad
  • In Assam, a controversy erupted after a picture of UPPL leader Benjamin Basumatary, lying on a stack of Rs 500 notes circulated on social media. UPPL is an ally of the BJP
  • AAP's Jalandhar-West MP Sushil Kumar Rinku joins the BJP. He was the only AAP Lok Sabha MP
  • Supreme Court dismisses Centre's plea to review its 2023 verdict in the PMLA case
  • Close save for passengers as they remain unhurt after the wings of two planes graze at Kolkata airport. Pilots derostered and inquiry ordered by DGCA
  • Bengal BJP leader Dilip Ghosh gets notice from the EC as well as the BJP for making ugly remarks about Mamata Banerjee's parentage
  • Sadanand Vasanth Date, who faught terrorists in the 26/11 attack and was awarded the Preisent's Police medal, has been appointed the head of the NIA
  • Centre will borrow Rs 7.5L cr in the first six months of FY25, nearly 50% of the target for the full year
  • 25 stocks, including SBI, will see same day trade settlements from today in the world's fastest settlement mode in both BSE and NSE
  • Stocks recover smartly on Wednesday: Sensex rises 526 points to 72996 and Nifty 118 points to 22123
  • Tennis: Rohan Bopanna-Matthew Ebden reached the semifinals of the Miami Open
Delhi Lt Governor Vinai Kumar Saxena says government cannot be run from jail, hints at President's Rule in the capital ////// In a dangerous incident, the wings of two planes grazed while taxiing on the runway at Kolkata airport, all passengers were safe but DGCA ordered an inquiry and the pilots were derostered
oppn parties
The Modi Government: Right In Being Firm On CAA, Wrong In Stifling Protests By Force

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2019-12-20 12:58:06

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator.

The Modi government is both right and wrong on the CAA. It is right in asserting that there will be no rollback of CAA. The government has been voted to power on the basis of its manifesto which included the fact that it will amend the Citizenship Act as it has done. It is right in saying that it has the power to enact legislation if the same is passed in parliament. Those who claim that the CAA is unconstitutional are only expressing their opinion as they neither have the ability nor the authority to declare this. Only the Supreme Court has that power and it has already admitted several petitions on the matter and issued a notice to the Centre in this regard.

But the government is wrong in using force to prevent peaceful protests against the CAA. It was wrong in sending the police inside Jamia Millia to break up peaceful protests by the students. It is wrong in invoking section 144 to disallow people from assembling to protest. It is wrong in detaining people like Ramchandra Guha for expressing his opinion against the CAA in a rally. It is wrong in giving the impression that only Muslims are protesting against the Act. It is wrong in suspending the internet in several places.

The government has to recognize that in a democracy, there will always be a substantial number of people who will not accept its policies or agree to the laws it chooses to enact. If everyone would have been on the same page with the government, it would have won with a 100 percent vote in its favour. This government has won with a little over 40 percent of the popular vote and is in power only because India follows a first-past-the-post electoral system. Hence, it should be prepared for dissent. It should allow people to protest peacefully if they do not like any of its policies or laws. It should desist from using force or colonial-era laws to stifle these protests.

At the same time, if the government thinks it is right in enacting the law, it should remain firm and put the law into practice. The proposed amendments to the Citizenship Act were in the public domain for long. In fact, the last bill introduced to amend the same had lapsed due to the termination of the term of the last Lok Sabha. In the present parliament, the opposition failed to unite in the Rajya Sabha despite its strong objection to the bill. Hence, it now has no excuse.

Instead of raising the mercury level in the country, it would be advisable for all to wait for the Supreme Court to decide the matter. If all laws to be enacted in India were subjected to a UN-monitored plebiscite, as suggested by West Bengal chief minister Mamata Banerjee (she has said that if the BJP "has the guts" it should agree to a UN-monitored referendum), no laws would get made. Further, the UN has no right to interfere in the matter. Only the Indian parliament can enact laws and the Supreme Court can rule whether they pass the Constitutional test.