oppn parties The Taj Controversy: Not Right to Disown Culture

News Snippets

  • The home ministry has notified 50% constable-level jobs in BSF for direct recruitment for ex-Agniveers
  • Supreme Court said that if an accused or even a convict obtains a NOC from the concerned court with the rider that permission would be needed to go abroad, the government cannot obstruct renewal of their passport
  • Supreme Court said that criminal record and gravity of offence play a big part in bail decisions while quashing the bail of 5 habitual offenders
  • PM Modi visits Bengal, fails to holds a rally in Matua heartland of Nadia after dense fog prevents landing of his helicopter but addresses the crowd virtually from Kolkata aiprort
  • Government firm on sim-linking for web access to messaging apps, but may increase the auto logout time from 6 hours to 12-18 hours
  • Mizoram-New Delhi Rajdhani Express hits an elephant herd in Assam, killing seven elephants including four calves
  • Indian women take on Sri Lanka is the first match of the T20 series at Visakhapatnam today
  • U19 Asia Cup: India take on Pakistan today for the crown
  • In a surprisng move, the selectors dropped Shubman Gill from the T20 World Cup squad and made Axar Patel the vice-captain. Jitesh Sharma was also dropped to make way for Ishan Kishan as he was performing well and Rinku Singh earned a spot for his finishing abilities
  • Opposition parties, chiefly the Congress and TMC, say that changing the name of the rural employment guarantee scheme is an insult to the memory of Mahatma Gandhi
  • Commerce secreatary Rajesh Agarwal said that the latest data shows that exporters are diversifying
  • Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman said that if India were a 'dead economy' as claimed by opposition parties, India's rating would not have been upgraded
  • The Insurance Bill, to be tabled in Parliament, will give more teeth to the regulator and allow 100% FDI
  • Nitin Nabin took charge as the national working president of the BJP
  • Division in opposition ranks as J&K chief minister Omar Abdullah distances the INDIA bloc from vote chori and SIR pitch of the Congress
U19 World Cup - Pakistan thrash India by 192 runs ////// Shubman Gill dropped from T20 World Cup squad, Axar Patel replaces him as vice-captain
oppn parties
The Taj Controversy: Not Right to Disown Culture

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2017-10-04 15:03:50

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator.
The omission of Taj Mahal from the booklet listing tourist attractions in UP, brought out on the occasion of completion of 6 months of the Yogi government, cannot be a “miscommunication”, as explained by state minister Sidharth Nath Singh. It is a deliberate attempt to exclude a World Heritage site and one of the Seven Wonders of the World. A clue to this was available when Yogi Adityanath had said sometime back that Taj Mahal did not reflect Indian culture. His government has also stopped giving replicas of the Taj to foreign dignitaries.

What is Indian culture? Is it not an amalgam of the cultures of all communities living in the country? Or is it limited to temple architecture? Is not India enriched by having such diversity? In any case, Yogi Adityanath is not an authority on Indian culture. His government is using the perks of office to impose its views. Obviously, this is just a passing phase.

But segregating heritage sites and monuments according to who built them is a dangerous trend. Going by this, the iconic Howrah Bridge in Kolkata or the Gateway of India should also vanish from lists of attractions in their respective states. Thankfully, not many people in the country think like Adityanath.

It is a disgraceful thing to compartmentalize culture. There is no Muslim architecture or Hindu architecture. All architecture is a reflection of the region from where people come. If people from Central Asia and Middle-East and Europe came and made India their home, they infused their own identity on Indian architecture and culture. Apart from typical minarets on Muslim architecture, India boasts of English, French, Portuguese and Dutch influence in places like Chandannagore, Pondicherry, Goa and Kerala, apart from cities like Delhi, Kolkata, Mumbai and Chennai. This bond has resulted in a uniqueness that is totally Indian, an amalgam of the cultures of all people who are Indians or had once ruled over the country.

Hence, the UP government and other BJP governments thinking along these lines would be well advised not to become the authority on deciding what comprises Indian culture. Indian culture is not limited to only Hindu culture. Let us celebrate the diversity of our culture and our people. Let us allow a million flowers to bloom instead of working towards spoiling the garden.