oppn parties What Should Be Done In Case Of False Rape Cases?

News Snippets

  • The Congress registered a decisive victory over the BJP in Rajasthan's rural local body elections, winning 3,701 Panchayat Samiti seats against the BJP's 2,181 and 599 Zila Parishad seats against 301, according to State Election Commission figures
  • India reiterated its rejection of a US civil lawsuit filed by Sikh separatist Gurpatwant Singh Pannun naming National Security Adviser Ajit Doval and former RAW chief Samant Goel, after a New York court authorised an alternative procedure for sending summonses through three Delhi district courts
  • Prime Minister Narendra Modi inaugurated the first Shanghai Cooperation Organisation Civilisational Dialogue Forum at Purana Qila in New Delhi, attended by Pakistan's Climate Change Minister Musadik Masood Malik, marking the first visit by a Pakistani federal minister since May 2023
  • Union Home Minister Amit Shah arrived in Itanagar for a three-day visit to Arunachal Pradesh, during which he is scheduled to review internal security and development, present the President's Police Colour to the state police and inaugurate an NDRF campus. The visit comes amid continuing opposition to the proposed 11,200 MW Siang Upper Multipurpose Project, with local communities raising concerns about environmental consequences and displacement
  • Severe Cyclonic Storm Akvan crossed the north Andhra Pradesh and south Odisha coasts near Gopalpur between approximately 7.30 am and 8.30 am, bringing winds of 70-80 kmph with gusts up to 90 kmph before weakening into a deep depression
  • The Supreme Court permitted the lighting of the Karthigai Deepam lamp this year at the disputed stone pillar near the Subramania Swamy Temple and Sikandar Badusha Dargah on Thiruparankundram hill in Madurai, but stayed the Madras High Court's observations concerning the nature of the pillar and the land. The permission is restricted to a small authorised temple team under district administration supervision, with public gatherings and processions prohibited and customary worship and access to the Dargah and mosque required to continue undisturbed; the one-time permission cannot establish a right for future years
  • The Supreme Court dismissed the Karnataka government's appeal against a High Court ruling allowing motorcycle owners and aggregators to operate bike-taxi services in the state. The decision preserves the right to seek registration and permits for such services, while leaving the state free to impose reasonable regulatory conditions
  • The Supreme Court ordered a fact-finding inquiry into why an Enforcement Directorate appeal challenging anticipatory bail granted to businessman Raman Singhal in a money-laundering case remained unlisted for nearly three years despite earlier judicial directions
  • The Supreme Court dismissed two applications by Tamil Nadu seeking directions to Karnataka to release an alleged outstanding 11 TMC of Cauvery water, with Tamil Nadu arguing that the shortfall was affecting standing crops during a rainfall-deficient year
  • SEBI proposed withdrawing additional disclosure requirements imposed on certain offshore funds in 2023, arguing that the rules could place India at a disadvantage compared with competing investment markets
  • SEBI proposed withdrawing additional disclosure requirements imposed on certain offshore funds in 2023, arguing that the rules could place India at a disadvantage compared with competing investment markets
  • The Indian rupee closed the week at 92.67 against the US dollar, strengthening past the 93-per-dollar level for the first time since April and recording its strongest session since October 12
  • Indian equity benchmarks extended their recovery on Friday, with the Sensex gaining 897.96 points, or 1.08 per cent, to close at 83,919.71 and the Nifty 50 advancing 286.30 points, or 1.12 per cent, to 25,800.60
  • India reached 159 for one at stumps on the second day of the opening Test against New Zealand in Wellington, replying to the hosts' first-innings total of 368. Yashasvi Jaiswal scored 85 off 89 balls before being dismissed, while KL Rahul remained unbeaten on 52 and Devdutt Padikkal on 16, leaving India 209 runs behind with nine wickets in hand
  • Jharkhand defeated Karnataka by seven wickets in the Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy after restricting them to 174 for nine and reaching 178 for three in 19.1 overs. In another match, Bengal defeated Mizoram by 93 runs
The Ganga water treaty between India and Bangladesh is at risk of lapsing as strained relarions between neighbours have not led to talks about its renewal
oppn parties
What Should Be Done In Case Of False Rape Cases?

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2018-08-23 19:33:33

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator. Author of Cyber Scams in India, Digital Arrest, The Money Trap and The Human Hack
After more than 10 years, the Supreme Court has acquitted two brothers who were found guilty of raping a (then) minor girl. But the persons have already served a long time in prison and their best years are gone – for no fault of theirs. Is acquittal a fair form of justice for them? Also, what about the accuser? Should she be let off without any punishment for making this false complaint and destroying their lives? What about investigating officers or public prosecutors and even the judge who delivered the wrong judgment? What should the law do in such a case?

In the instant case, in August 2001, a minor girl complained that two uncles of her took her to their home and raped her in the presence of their family after tying her to a cot. Since the medical report did not substantiate rape, the trial court acquitted the accused. But the girl appealed to the High Court which ordered a retrial. The accused were convicted in the retrial and the High Court upheld the conviction. Since then, pending their appeal in the apex court, the accused have been spending time in jail.

On examining the material on record, the Supreme Court was scathing in blaming the prosecution for relying on “assumptions, surmises and conjectures.” It also termed the evidence of the ‘victim’ and her aunts as “unreliable and untrustworthy” as it was full of “contradictions and improbabilities”. Hence, the court released the accused as not guilty. In setting aside the previous judgment, the court said that “the findings of the courts below do not deserve the merit of acceptance or approval in our hands with regard to glaring infirmities and illegalities vitiating them and the patent errors apparent on the face of record resulting in serious and grave miscarriage of justice to the appellant”.

While this is good news for the accused, is this fair justice? Who will compensate for the years they lost in jail for a crime they did not commit? Or the loss of reputation they have suffered? How should the law deal with the girl who filed the false charge or her family who gave false evidence? Is prosecuting them under sections 182, 193, 195 and 211 of IPC and section 340 of CrPC enough, or is it even necessary? One thinks that once the Supreme Court decides that the rape case does not stand, the contrary is also true – that the charge that was filed was false. Hence, there is no need to linger the case by prosecuting the accuser and her co-conspirators under the above section. The charge of falsely filing the case is proven by the Supreme Court order. They must be arrested forthwith and given the maximum sentence allowed under any of the above sections. In addition, they must be made to pay the accused for the time spent in jail by applying a formula of how much they would have earned if they were working. The law can be suitably amended to carry this out.

The apex court must also think of a way to punish the prosecutors and investigating officers as it seems to be a clear case of building a false case for favours received. If, as the Supreme Court has said, the previous judgments were so full of “patent errors apparent on the face of record resulting in serious and grave miscarriage of justice to the appellant” then the court must also devise a way to punish judges who delivered those judgments. No one should be allowed to play games with investigation, prosecution and justice as it seems to have been done in this case.