oppn parties Appointing Judges: Stop Politicizing, Find A Solution Fast

News Snippets

  • SP drops two candidates owing allegiance to Azam Khan from Rampur and Moradabad
  • In Assam, a controversy erupted after a picture of UPPL leader Benjamin Basumatary, lying on a stack of Rs 500 notes circulated on social media. UPPL is an ally of the BJP
  • AAP's Jalandhar-West MP Sushil Kumar Rinku joins the BJP. He was the only AAP Lok Sabha MP
  • Supreme Court dismisses Centre's plea to review its 2023 verdict in the PMLA case
  • Close save for passengers as they remain unhurt after the wings of two planes graze at Kolkata airport. Pilots derostered and inquiry ordered by DGCA
  • Bengal BJP leader Dilip Ghosh gets notice from the EC as well as the BJP for making ugly remarks about Mamata Banerjee's parentage
  • Sadanand Vasanth Date, who faught terrorists in the 26/11 attack and was awarded the Preisent's Police medal, has been appointed the head of the NIA
  • Centre will borrow Rs 7.5L cr in the first six months of FY25, nearly 50% of the target for the full year
  • 25 stocks, including SBI, will see same day trade settlements from today in the world's fastest settlement mode in both BSE and NSE
  • Stocks recover smartly on Wednesday: Sensex rises 526 points to 72996 and Nifty 118 points to 22123
  • Tennis: Rohan Bopanna-Matthew Ebden reached the semifinals of the Miami Open
  • IPL: records tumble as SRH beat MI in a high-scoring match. SRH score 277/3 with 18 sixes and Mumbai score 246 with 20 sixes to fall short by 31 runs. Atotal of 38 sixes, highest in an IPL match were hit and both teams combined to score 523 runs, the highest aggregate in an IPL match
  • Amul will launch fresh milk in the US
  • IPL: RCB beat Punjab by 4 wickets as Kohli and Karthik shine with the bat
  • India strongly objected to German foreign office remarks over the arrest of delhi CM Arvind Kejriwal, called it "biased assumptions"
Delhi Lt Governor Vinai Kumar Saxena says government cannot be run from jail, hints at President's Rule in the capital ////// In a dangerous incident, the wings of two planes grazed while taxiing on the runway at Kolkata airport, all passengers were safe but DGCA ordered an inquiry and the pilots were derostered
oppn parties
Appointing Judges: Stop Politicizing, Find A Solution Fast

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2018-04-27 12:50:46

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator.
Several things arise out of the government’s decision not to pass the recommendation made by the collegium to elevate Justice K M Joseph to the Supreme Court. Can the government legally do this? Or is the collegium recommendation binding on the government? Obviously, the government can ask the collegium to reconsider its decision. This has been clarified by the CJI when lawyer Indira Jaisingh filed a case to block Indu Malhotra’s elevation saying that it has to be all or none, meaning that either both Malhotra and Justice Joseph be elevated or none should be. The Supreme Court did not agree and Malhotra will take oath on Friday while the collegium might resend Justice Joseph’s name to the government.

But some of the reasons given by the government do not hold water. For instance, the government has said that Justice Joseph’s parent high court, the Kerala High Court, is already represented in Supreme Court and given its small size, there is no need to appoint more from there. But there are several high courts - Bombay and Delhi for example - that have many representatives on the apex court benches. Quality, not regional quota, should be the benchmark when appointing judges and Justice Joseph is not found wanting there. So the government must not block someone who has been selected by his peers after due diligence. The elevation should have been blocked only on receiving a negative intelligence report. It seems the government wants to escalate its tiff with the judiciary by blocking this appointment.

But the other charge by the Congress that the government is “cherry-picking” and does not want judges inimical to it to sit on Supreme Court benches does not hold water. In fact, the reverse would mean that all selected judges will toe the government line. This is highly insulting to Indu Malhotra now and to others who will be elevated till the NDA is in power. Further, the government is right in saying that the Congress has no moral authority to criticize the NDA as it was the worst offender when it came to appointing preferred judges or superseding senior judges to make a blue-eyed judge the chief justice.But two wrongs do not make a right. In fact, the whole thing about politicizing judges’ appointment has gone too far and if a permanent solution is not found urgently, the judiciary will cease to be independent, justice will suffer due to paucity of judges and people will lose faith in the system.

image courtesy: livelaw.in