oppn parties Criminal Intent Must To Attract Sec. 306 of IPC

News Snippets

  • UP Police have arrested three government officials and 9 others for the murder of journalist and RTI activist Raghvendra Bajpai in Sitapur
  • Union minister Jitendra Singh said terrorists were behind the killing of three persons in Marhoon village in Kathua district of J&K
  • Uneasy calm remains in Manipur as tribal areas shut down after the Kuki-Zo Council called for an indefinite shutdown
  • Indian drug manufacturers are set to produce Emplagliflozin at a tenth of the price of the innovator Boehringer Ingelheim, after its patent expires on March 11. The companies in the running are Mankind, Torrent, Alkem, Dr Reddys and Lupin
  • The Budget session of Parliament will resume today against the backdrop of ongoing tussle over delimitation and three-language formula
  • Police have arrested a third suspect in the horrific rape-murder of foreign tourists and their Indian friend in Hampi in Karnataka
  • Stock brokers are upbeat that the present downtrend in the markets will see a reversal in March with reports by international analysts suggesting that the worst in the tariff war between the US and China and other nations almost over.
  • The Centre is in the process of implementing a 23-point agenda for regulation and reforms in areas like land, labour, utilities and permits to make life easier for businesses across the country
  • Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman said that if businessmen take one step, the government is ready to take 10 steps with them
  • Rohit Sharma, Shreyas Iyer, K L Rahul shine with the bat after the spinner restrict New Zealand to just 251
  • Unbeaten India lift the ICC Champions Trophy by beating New Zealand by 4 wickets
  • 2nd ODI: Rohit Sharma roars back to form with a scintillating ton as India beat England by 4 wickets in a high scoring match in Cuttack
  • Supreme Court will appoint an observer for the mayoral poll in Chandigarh
  • Government makes it compulsory for plastic carry bag makers to put a QR or barcode with their details on such bags
  • GBS outbreak in Pune leaves 73 ill with 14 on ventilator. GBS is a rare but treatable autoimmune disease
Audacious gun-point robbery at a jewellery showroom in Ara in Bihar /////// Bhojpur Police chase the robbers and arrest two of them after a gunfight /////// Four gang members still at large /////// Jewellery worth Rs 15cr recovered from the total Rs 23cr worth looted, with one bag still missing
oppn parties
Criminal Intent Must To Attract Sec. 306 of IPC

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2018-06-27 12:11:50

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator.
The Supreme Court has ruled that a superior cannot be charged with abetting the suicide of his junior if the latter ends his life due to workload related depression, if criminal intent cannot be proved. This is an eminently wise decision that has far reaching implications at the work place. Work and its quantum cannot be defined in exact terms. Some people consider opening a file to be extremely burdensome work. Others cannot manage their time efficiently and bring burden upon themselves. Hence, what is child’s play for some can be tiresome workload for others.

In the instant case, the wife of deceased Kishor Parashar filed a police complaint saying that her husband committed suicide as he was put to tremendous mental agony as his superior was burdening him with extreme work load that required him to work from 10 am to 10 pm and even on holidays or odd hours. The Aurangabad bench of the Bombay High Court had then held that culpability could exist even if there was no direct abetment on the grounds that the superior could create situations that could lead to unbearable mental tension. The high court refused to quash the FIR.

Aggrieved by this, the charged officer approached the Supreme Court. In the case Vaijnath Kondiba Khandke vs. State of Maharashtra, the apex court ruled that the logic applied by the Bombay HC was untenable. The court held that mere assigning of work or even stopping salary for a month could not be construed as abetment to suicide if guilty mind or criminal intent were not proved. Sec. 306 of IPC could only be invoked in criminal intent was proved.

A division bench of JusticeArun Mishra and Justice UU Lalit said that “it is true that if a situation is created deliberately so as to drive a person to commit suicide, there would be room for attracting Section 306 IPC. However, the facts on record in the present case are completely inadequate and insufficient.”

The court also said that “as a superior officer, if some work was assigned by the applicant to the deceased, merely on that count it cannot be said that there was any guilty mind or criminal intent. The exigencies of work and the situation may call for certain action on part of a superior including stopping of salary of a junior officer for a month. That action simplicitor cannot be considered to be a pointer against such superior officer. The allegations in the FIR are completely inadequate and do not satisfy the requirements under Section 306 IPC.”

If the SC had upheld the Bombay HC judgment, no superior could have ever assigned work to any junior or could have disciplined him for shirking work. In the absence of what constitutes optimum work that can be assigned to any person, most junior employees would have accused their superiors of driving him to depression and possible suicide. It would have thrown workplaces into chaos and indiscipline would have ruled. With this judgment, that gross situation will be avoided.