oppn parties Denying Backward Caste Rights to Muslim or Christian Dalits: The Government Is Legally & Logically Correct

News Snippets

  • For the first time ever, Mukesh Ambani buys a 29% stake in Gautam Adani's Mahan Energen, a subsidiary of Adani Power to source 500MW of electricity from the company's power plant in MP
  • Stocks continue to rise on Thursday - Sensex gains 639 points to 73635 and Nifty 203 points to 22326
  • Golf - Indian Open: 3 Indians at tied 14th as Joost Luiten takes the lead with a wonderful 7-under 65
  • IPL: RR beat DC by 12 runs as Riyan Parag (84 off just 45 balls) shines
  • SP drops two candidates owing allegiance to Azam Khan from Rampur and Moradabad
  • In Assam, a controversy erupted after a picture of UPPL leader Benjamin Basumatary, lying on a stack of Rs 500 notes circulated on social media. UPPL is an ally of the BJP
  • AAP's Jalandhar-West MP Sushil Kumar Rinku joins the BJP. He was the only AAP Lok Sabha MP
  • Supreme Court dismisses Centre's plea to review its 2023 verdict in the PMLA case
  • Close save for passengers as they remain unhurt after the wings of two planes graze at Kolkata airport. Pilots derostered and inquiry ordered by DGCA
  • Bengal BJP leader Dilip Ghosh gets notice from the EC as well as the BJP for making ugly remarks about Mamata Banerjee's parentage
  • Sadanand Vasanth Date, who faught terrorists in the 26/11 attack and was awarded the Preisent's Police medal, has been appointed the head of the NIA
  • Centre will borrow Rs 7.5L cr in the first six months of FY25, nearly 50% of the target for the full year
  • 25 stocks, including SBI, will see same day trade settlements from today in the world's fastest settlement mode in both BSE and NSE
  • Stocks recover smartly on Wednesday: Sensex rises 526 points to 72996 and Nifty 118 points to 22123
  • Tennis: Rohan Bopanna-Matthew Ebden reached the semifinals of the Miami Open
Delhi Lt Governor Vinai Kumar Saxena says government cannot be run from jail, hints at President's Rule in the capital ////// In a dangerous incident, the wings of two planes grazed while taxiing on the runway at Kolkata airport, all passengers were safe but DGCA ordered an inquiry and the pilots were derostered
oppn parties
Denying Backward Caste Rights to Muslim or Christian Dalits: The Government Is Legally & Logically Correct

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2022-11-12 07:32:43

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator.

The Central government has submitted in the Supreme Court that since the caste system is related to Hinduism and the Constitution proposed affirmative action for these marginalized sections of the Hindu society, anyone who converts from Hinduism, Sikhism or Buddhism (Sikh backwards were included in 1956 and Buddhists in 1990) to any other faith loses the benefits of being a backward caste since no other religion subscribes to the caste system. Hence, once they convert, they are assimilated in the general fabric of the followers of their new religion and are not identified by their caste.

The government also argued that the Constitution (SC) Order, 1950 was legal and valid as it was not in conflict with the Constitution. It also said that the Justice Ranganath Mishra Commission took a narrow and myopic view of the issue while recommending the inclusion of Dalit Muslims and Christians in the list and its findings were flawed.

The government said that "the Constitution (SC) Order 1950 was based on historical data which clearly established that no such backwardness or oppression was ever faced by members of Christian or Islamic society. In fact, one of the reasons for which people from Scheduled Castes have been converting to religions like Islam or Christianity is so that they can come out of the oppressive system of untouchability which is not prevalent at all in Christianity and Islam".

This is true if one sees it only from the view of religions. Both Islam and Christianity have a casteless society. Hence, if Dalits convert to either of the two religions, they lose the socially backward status they were subjected to under the Hindu society. Religiously and theoretically, there are no Dalit Muslims or Dalit Christians. That removes the main reason for allowing them the benefits that are available only for those identified under the 1950 order which excludes followers of Islam and Christianity. The Misra commission had opined that the Schedule Caste net should be religiously neutral. But if a religion is caste neutral, how can its adherents demand backward caste status?

But given the age old bias against the backward classes in India, it is seen that even in the casteless society of Islam and Christianity, these converts from backward classes are looked down upon in India. Still, purely from the legal point of view, the government's argument cannot be flawed and such converts cannot be allowed to enjoy the benefits available to backward classes once they embrace a religion that does not treat them as such.