oppn parties Even "Time-Tested" Laws Need To Be Re-Examined As Times Keep Changing

News Snippets

  • Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi told an interaction at Columbia University that India was sitting on an economic disaster, citing unemployment, weaknesses in the education system and the lack of career prospects for young people. The BJP accused him of running an anti-India campaign abroad, while Congress spokesperson Pawan Khera said the government appeared more concerned about Gandhi discussing economic problems than addressing them
  • The Madhya Pradesh Cabinet approved the removal of the two-child restriction for government employment, ending a provision that had been in force for nearly 25 years. Disciplinary proceedings initiated solely because an employee had more than two living children will also be withdrawn under the approved amendments to the Madhya Pradesh Civil Services Rules, 1961
  • Prime Minister Narendra Modi urged ministers and senior officials to make the fight against substance abuse among young people a national priority, comparing the effort required with the government's campaign against Naxalism
  • The Supreme Court issued a show-cause notice to advocate Pravin Singhal on a Supreme Court Bar Association petition seeking criminal contempt proceedings over allegedly derogatory remarks against Chief Justice of India Surya Kant during open-court proceedings on November 16
  • The Madras High Court declined to lift the construction restrictions within a one-kilometre radius of Chennai's Pallikaranai Marshland Ramsar Site, holding that the Supreme Court was already supervising the wetland's boundary demarcation. The state had proposed reducing the restricted Zone of Influence from 3,474 hectares to 128.19 hectares, but the High Court said the revised boundaries remained provisional pending scientific ground-truthing and allowed the petitioners to approach the Supreme Court for relief
  • Security forces killed Lashkar-e-Taiba commander Mohammed Lateef Bhat in an encounter at Zangalpora village in Jammu and Kashmir's Kulgam district after he refused repeated appeals to surrender during a standoff at a mosque
  • Severe Cyclonic Storm Akvan continued moving towards the eastern coast, with the IMD's latest forecast placing its likely landfall between Machilipatnam in Andhra Pradesh and Puri in Odisha around noon on November 20, with sustained winds of 100-110 kmph and gusts up to 120 kmph
  • Around 60 students at a private school in Kottiyam, Kollam district, were taken to hospital after reporting nausea, breathing difficulties, itching and other complaints allegedly linked to pollution from a nearby tar-mixing unit
  • A major fire broke out at Pune's Timber Market around 2.05 am, damaging an estimated 50 to 60 shops dealing in wood and timber products. Twenty-seven fire tenders and around 150 personnel brought the blaze under control after nearly two hours
  • The Madhya Pradesh Cabinet cleared investment proposals worth Rs 70,650 crore, projected to generate around 3.14 lakh jobs across the state. The projects include agro, chemical, bio-pharma and textile parks, a 200 MW floating solar project and an 800 MW battery storage system at Omkareshwar, alongside additional support for MSME development
  • Indian equity benchmarks snapped their two-session winning run, with the Sensex falling 500.38 points, or 0.61 per cent, to 82,031.81 and the Nifty 50 declining 159.45 points, or 0.63 per cent, to 25,227.95
  • Lakshya Sen secured qualification for the BWF World Tour Finals after Japan's Koki Watanabe lost to Kidambi Srikanth in the first round of the Hong Kong Open Super 500. Sen had earlier beaten France's Arnaud Merkle in three games, while Srikanth defeated Watanabe 21-16, 16-21, 21-9 and Rakshitha Ramraj upset world No. 20 Mia Blichfeldt 21-18, 21-18
  • India Under-19 women defeated Nepal by 142 runs in the Women's Under-19 T20 Tri-Series in Bengaluru, posting 218 for four before restricting Nepal to 76 for seven. Ishwari Awasare led the Indian batting with 75 off 37 balls and was named Player of the Match
  • Bihar produced a last-over upset in the Syed Mushtaq Ali Trophy, chasing down Delhi's 225-run target to win by two wickets with one ball remaining. Yash Dhull's 125 off 59 balls, including 16 fours and seven sixes, and Tejasvi Dahiya's 51 had taken Delhi to 224 for five, but Bihar finished at 227 for eight after a decisive ninth-wicket partnership
  • The All India Football Federation lodged a formal complaint with the Asian Football Confederation over an alleged racist gesture by Palestine midfielder Taha Soueidan towards India Under-17 captain Dallalmoun Gangte during their November 17 Asian Cup qualifier. Soueidan denied racist intent and said the gesture was a spontaneous reaction to the humidity in Malaysia; AIFF has asked the AFC to examine the match footage and take appropriate action, while India had won the match 4-1
Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi told an interaction at Columbia University that India was sitting on an economic disaster, citing unemployment, weaknesses in the education system and the lack of career prospects for young people
oppn parties
Even "Time-Tested" Laws Need To Be Re-Examined As Times Keep Changing

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2022-05-08 10:12:27

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator. Author of Cyber Scams in India, Digital Arrest, The Money Trap and The Human Hack

The Centre supported Section 124A of the IPC (commonly referred to as the sedition law) in the Supreme Court. In its opinion, there is no need to re-examine the Kedar Nath judgment as "instances of abuse of provision would never be a justification to reconsider a binding judgment". It further said that the court should provide a remedy that stops misuse without "doubting a longstanding settled law declared by a Constitution bench for about 6 decades".

The Centre is wrong on many counts. The need to take a relook at both the constitutional validity of Section 124A and the Kedar Nath judgment has arisen precisely because the Constitutional bench in 1962 had upheld the validity of the section and provided guidelines to prevent its misuse but in these 60 years, the guidelines have failed to have the necessary effect and the misuse of the section has not stopped. It is ironical that a regime that has accelerated and widened the misuse of the section is now saying that the court should provide further guidelines to prevent the misuse. If only successive governments had applied Section 124A in both letter and spirit and had treated the Kedar Nath judgment and the guidelines therein as binding, a situation where citizens have to plead before the Supreme Court to take a relook at the provision would not have arisen in the first place.

Further, society undergoes changes due to evolving cultural norms and introduction of technology, among many other reasons. Laws are also changed periodically to keep them up to date with emerging trends. Six decades is a long time and there is absolutely no harm if the apex court reconsiders the earlier judgment. The need to re-examine a "time-tested" law or judgment arises because times keep changing. There was no social media and mobile phones in 1962. Television had just made an appearance in late 1959 and only government sponsored news was broadcast.  Politics was not so utterly divided and polarized. In these six decades a lot has changed and infinitely more people are getting their voices heard through social media. Also, governments have become thin-skinned and cannot tolerate even constructive criticism, let alone outright dissent. Section 124A is now being so commonly used that it seems it is being used for petty crimes. The time is perfectly ripe for the Supreme Court to take another look whether Section 124A meets the constitutional test since the Kedar Nath judgment, which could not have anticipated the huge advancement in technology, has failed to prevent its growing misuse.