oppn parties Grand Alliance in J & K Would be Unholy

News Snippets

  • PM Modi says anti-India forces are against him but he will not bend
  • Campaigning ends for the 6th and penultimate phase of polling for the 2024 general elections. Voting on Saturday, May 25
  • Arvind Kejriwal waits at home but Delhi cops did not turn up to question him and his family in the Swati Maliwal case
  • Delhi HC denies bail to Manish Sisodia, says non-recovery of cash not a proof that there was no corruption
  • H D Deve Gowda asks his grandson Prajwal Revanna, accused in rape and sexual molestation cases, to return to India or face his anger
  • Kolkata cops search for Bangladeshi MP Anwarul Azim Anar's chopped body parts in Bangar, near Kolkata. The MP was murdered in an apartment complex in New Town, Kolkata by opponents from bangladesh who hired a contract killer for the job
  • Clashes break out in Bengal's Nandigram as a BJP worker's mother is killed by miscreants
  • Google in talks with Foxconn to make Pixel phones and drones from plant near Chennai
  • Survey by S&P Global shows that business activity was robust in May and job creation was highest in 18 years
  • Indigo reports Rs 1895cr profit in Q4 last fiscal, and nearly $ 1bn in FY23-24, a record for Indian carriers. Proposes business class in busiest and busy routes
  • Stocks on fire on Thursday after initial uncertainty: Sensex gains 1196 points to 75418 and Nifty 369 points to 22967
  • Ricky Ponting turns down offer to coach Team India, says will not fit in his lifestyle
  • World Cup stage II archery: Pramatesh Fuge enter semifinals but men's and women's recurve teams lose their matches in the first round
  • Malaysian Open badminton: P V Sindhu enters third round after a scare and Ashmta Chaliha stuns third seed Beiwen Zhang of USA to enter third round too
  • Sharjah Challenge chess: Divya deshmukh wins title
Record RBI dividend to government spurs a rally in stock markets, Sensex and Nifty touch all-time highs intra-day on Thursday
oppn parties
Grand Alliance in J & K Would be Unholy

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2014-12-30 19:27:23

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator.
Despite having won the highest percentage of votes in J & K, the BJP and its President Amit Shah will not have rejoiced much. This is due to the fact that their Mission 44 failed by a long margin. Especially galling would be the fact that despite winning the Ladhakh parliamentary seat in May 2014, they failed to win a single assembly seat in the region. Also, they were cocksure of winning all in Jammu region. But the Congress managed to win some. That they would draw a blank in the valley had become clear when the region witnessed the highest ever turnout (which was seen as an attempt by the people to keep the BJP out). But they got only 2% votes there, which must have come as a shock. Such a large swing in its favour, as happened in J & K, would have got the BJP an absolute majority in many states. But as the composition of the electorate in the Valley is tricky, the BJP landed with just 25 seats. Of course, Shah can now go back and say that it was because 44 was set as a target that they got the number of seats they did, it remains a fact that despite an all out effort, the people of the Valley and Ladhakh regions could not be won over.

Now, as parties grapple with government formation in a hung house, the question that arises is this: will politicians from the Valley rule over Jammu, a region that has categorically rejected them? Or will politicians from Jammu rule over the Valley, similarly a region that has rejected them? One thinks that the best scenario would be for the BJP and the PDP to come together to rule by rotation, say two terms of one and half year for each party. That would ensure that the aspirations of the people of both regions get a look in.

Although this is quite possible, the only stumbling block would be the diametrically opposite views both parties have on Article 370. But that can be kept in abeyance in the interests of the state. There have been talks of forming a grand alliance that includes the PDP, the NC and the Congress. Any alliance of this kind would be an opportunistic one, cobbled together just to keep the BJP out. But would that be in the best interests of the state? After all, 23 percent of the people voted for the BJP, the highest number any party got in the state. That they were mostly from the Jammu region is makes it all the more necessary that the party is part of any government at Srinagar. For the state is Jammu and Kashmir and not only Kashmir. This should be kept in mind by all parties before they embark on any deal that could turn out to be harmful for the state in the long run.

The parties should also remember that the alternative to their dilly-dallying would be governorâ€â"¢s rule, which should be the last resort in any democracy. Further, governorâ€â"¢s rule would be BJPâ€â"¢s rule by proxy, a thing these parties want to avoid by keeping the party out of government formation. Hence, any government in the state should include both the BJP and the PDP, the two parties that have won the largest number of votes and seats.