oppn parties Pakistan Asked To Be Fair To Kulbhushan Jadhav

News Snippets

  • Mobile operators Vodafone-Idea and Airtel decide to raise tariffs from next month
  • Sharad Pawar meets Sonia Gandhi and says more time needed for government formation in Maharashtra
  • Justice S A Bobde sworn in as the 47th Chief Justice of India
  • Supreme Court holds hotels liable for theft of vehicle from their parking area if parked by valet, says "owner's risk" clause is not a shield from such liability
  • Finance Minister says she is receiving feedback from many sectors that recovery is happening as there is lower stress
  • Sabarimala temple opens, but police bar the entry of women below 50 years
  • Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman says Air India and BPCL to be sold off by March
  • Media person Rajat Sharma resigns as DDCA president
  • Shiv Sena, NCP and Congress postpone meeting the governor of Maharashtra
  • Shiv Sena not to attend the NDA meeting on 17th November, says break up "a formality"
  • Shiv Sena says that the confidence the BJP is showing about forming the government in Maharashtra is based purely on its expectation of getting numbers through horse trading
  • Anil Ambani resigns as director of the bankrupt Reliance Communications
  • India beat Bangladesh by an innings and 150 rums inside three days in the first Test. Indian pacers excel after Mayank Agarwal's double century
  • Sena-NCP-Congress work out a common minimum programme, will form the government soon and it will last 5 years, says Sharad Pawar
  • Income Tax Appellate Tribunal upholds the decision to withdraw the charitable status of Young India, making it liable to pay Rs 145 in income tax. Rahul Gandhi and Priyanka Vadra are the majority shareholders in the company
Two Muslim litigants in Ayodhya refuse to accept the Supreme Court order, say review petition might be filed
oppn parties
Pakistan Asked To Be Fair To Kulbhushan Jadhav

By Sunil Garodia

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator. Writes for a number of publications.

Both India and Pakistan can claim to have won in the Kulbhushan Jadhav case in the International Court of Justice as the court issued a balanced order. But after a proper reading of the order, it becomes clear that barring annulment of Pakistan's military court proceedings that ordered Jadhav's execution on charges of spying, the ICJ has agreed to most of India's pleas. It is obvious that annulment can only be ordered if the order for execution stands after Pakistan reviews the decision as per the present ICJ order, allows consular access and proper legal representation to Jadhav during the review proceedings and if the ICJ finds it improper after such review.

It was India's contention that Pakistan had not followed due process in the Jadhav case by denying India consular access to the accused, by not allowing legal representation to the accused and by rushing through the proceedings. The ICJ concurred on all counts and directed that the execution be stayed, consular access be granted to India and the order to execute Jadhav be reviewed by Pakistan. It is not legally feasible to obtain an annulment order without giving the ordering authority a chance to set things right by reviewing its order. Hence, India's plea to annul should be viewed as a standard drafting procedure and arguments in regard to that will come later.

It is now up to Pakistan to ensure a fair trial for Kulbhushan Jadhav. Since the eyes of the entire world will now be focused on what it does next, Pakistan cannot assign the case to a military court once more where no outsiders are allowed. It will now have to get the case heard in a proper criminal court as per the Constitution of Pakistan. It will have to allow India consular access to Jadhav. It will also have to allow lawyers to represent Jadhav during the trial. A summary review will not do now. Any attempt to avoid the rule of law will prompt India to approach the ICJ again. The ICJ may then choose to annul the execution order and ensure that Jadhav is returned to India.