oppn parties POCSO Act Cannot be Extended to Mentally Retarded Adults

News Snippets

  • For the first time in history, Darjeeling loses first flush tea due to suspension of garden work for Covid-19 outbreak
  • Supreme Court asks journalists to be responsible and publish only the official version of news after it was brought to its notice that migrant exodus started after the 'fake' news that the lockdown will be extended to three months
  • Small saving rates slashed by the government by 140 basis points
  • The Centre says that the exodus of the migrants was stopped to save villages and prevent community transmission
  • The Centre says March 31 will remain the closing date for FY 2019-2020 and no change will be made for Covid-19 disruption
  • Tablighi Jamaat fiasco puts several states on high alert, attendees and their contacts being traced
  • Stock markets recover on the last day of the financial year, but the sentiment remains weak
  • The government says Covid-19 is still in local transmission stage in India
  • Government scotches rumours of extending the lockdown beyond April14. Says no such plan
  • Centre asks states to give shelter and food to migrant workers to stop them from taking to the streets
  • RBI cuts repo rate by 75 bps, the steepest in 10 years
  • Centre writes to states regarding laxity in monitoring people who had arrived from abroad between January and March
  • Kerala reports a spurt in new cases
  • With 124 fresh cases on Friday, the number of reported cases in India stand at 854
  • Five of a family, including a 9-month-old-baby test positive for Covid-19 in Nadia district in West Bengal on Friday
Total count stands ar 3082 as India records 16 Covid-19 deaths, the highest in a single day
oppn parties
POCSO Act Cannot be Extended to Mentally Retarded Adults

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2017-07-27 21:08:52

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator. Writes for a number of publications.
The Supreme Court has refused to extend the scope of Prevention of Children from Sexual Offences Act (POCSO), 2012 to mentally retarded adults. This is a correct stance as the judges themselves stated that it would amount to judicial overreach as well as it would try to bracket mentally retarded persons in a pre-set chamber whereas the disease has many angles and has to be examined technically.

The case on hand was that of a 38-year old suffering from cerebral palsy who was raped. The father of the victim contented before the court that since his daughter had the mental age equivalent to a “6 or 8 year old child,” her case should be tried according to provisions in the POCSO Act. The judges categorically stated that it was not the intention of the legislature to have such cases tried under the POCSO Act.

The court took pains to explain that the underlying theme behind the POCSO Act was to prevent children who were physically under 18 years of age from predators who, taking advantage of their lack of understanding of the situation and often through their position of trust molested them sexually. The court said it was upon the legislature to examine various facets and decide whether sexual crimes against mentally retarded adults having the mental age of a child below 18 could be tried under the Act.

The POCSO Act was enacted specifically to protect children under the age of 18. Although it is debatable whether the 18-year threshold is correct in this age and time, the idea behind the act is clear. Hence, if it was extended to mentally retarded adults, the focus of the act would get diluted. There is no doubt that cases of sexual crimes against such persons cannot be tried normally as the victim is incapable of providing evidence like a normal person. Hence, there should either be a separate law to deal with such cases or the Supreme Court should issue guidelines that the lower courts must adhere to while dealing with such cases. But these cases cannot, and should not, be tried under POCSO Act, nor should the Act be amended to include such cases within its ambit.