oppn parties Rahul Gandhi Convicted For Defamation In 'Modi Surname' Case, Sentenced To Two Years In Prison, Allowed 30 Days To Appeal

Story Of The Day

India Cannot Afford Delay: The NCW Is Right To Demand Stronger Laws Against Online Grooming
OPINIONS : Strongly Expressed

November 26, 2025

People Are Talking About

People Are Talking About The Twists And Turns In The Nikki Dowry Murder Case

News Snippets

  • Justice Surya Kaqnt sworn in as the 53rd CJI. Says free speech needs to be strengthened
  • Plume originating from volacnic ash in Ehtiopia might delay flights in India today
  • Supreme Court drops the fraud case against the Sandesaras brothers after they agree to pay back Rs 5100 cr. It gives them time till Dec 17 to deposit the money. The court took pains to say that this order should not be seen as a precedent in such crimes.
  • Chinese authorities detain a woman from Arunachal Pradesh who was travelling with her Indian passport. India lodges strong protest
  • S&P predicts India's economy to grow at 6.5% in FY26
  • The December MPC meet of RBI may reduce rates as the nation has seen steaqdy growth with little or no inflation
  • World Boxing Cup Finals: Hitesh Gulia wins gold in 70kgs
  • Kabaddi World Cup: Indian Women win their second consecutive title at Dhaka, beating Taipei 35-28
  • Second Test versus South Africa: M Jansen destroys India as the hosts lose all hopes of squaring the series. India out for 201, conceding a lead of 288 runs which effectively means that South Africa are set to win the match and the series
  • Defence minister Rajnath Singh said that Sindh may be back in India
  • After its total rejection by voters in Bihar, the Congress high command said that it happened to to 'vote chori' by the NDA and forced elimination of voters in the SIR
  • Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA) fined a Patna cafe Rs 30000 for adding service charge on the bill of a customer after it was found that the billing software at the cafe was doing it for all patrons
  • Kolkata HC rules that the sewadars (managers) of a debuttar (Deity's) property need not take permission from the court for developing the property
  • Ministry of Home Affairs said that there were no plans to introduce a bill to change the status of Chandigarh in the ensuing winter session of Parliament
  • A 20-year-old escort and her agent were held in connection with the murder of a CA in a Kolkata hotel
Iconic actor Dharmendra is no more, cremated at Pawan Hans crematorium in Juhu, Mumbai
oppn parties
Rahul Gandhi Convicted For Defamation In 'Modi Surname' Case, Sentenced To Two Years In Prison, Allowed 30 Days To Appeal

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2023-03-23 10:21:42

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator.

A Surat court has sentenced Rahul Gandhi to 2 years in prison in a criminal defamation case dating back to 2019. Campaigning for the 2019 general elections, the Congress leader (then the president of the party) had said 'why do all thieves have Modi as their surname'. While he was ostensibly referring to Narendra Modi (whom he had also accused of being thief by coining the slogan "chowkidar chor hai"), Neerav Modi (the diamond merchant who had fled the country after defrauding banks) and Lalit Modi (the architect of the IPL who was accused of swindling funds by the BCCI), he unwittingly also defamed and angered lakhs of people whose surname is Modi. This correspondent has written then that Rahul Gandhi must apologize to the countless Modis he had offended but he did not. The case against Gandhi was filed by BJP MLA and former Gujarat minister Purnesh Modi.

Rahul Gandhi, who was present in the Surat court, was granted bail by the court which suspended the punishment and allowed him 30 days to appeal in a higher court. As per the law, MPs and MLAs can be disqualified from membership of the legislative house if they are sentenced to two years or more in a criminal case. But such disqualification does not kick off immediately on pronouncement of the judgment in case of sitting members. They have three months to appeal and the disqualification (for a period equal to the sentence and six more years) will be applicable if the appeal goes against them. It is obvious that Rahul Gandhi will appeal against the sentence and the matter will finally reach the Supreme Court.

While the BJP welcomed the verdict and charged Gandhi with defaming an entire community, Congress workers protested at many places in Gujarat and elsewhere in the country. The Congress said that Gandhi will file an appeal against the verdict.

Read the 2019 article here

Other Stories You Make Like

Editorials

The Supreme Court's Governor Verdict Keeps India in the Gray Zone

The Supreme Court's Governor Verdict Keeps India in the Gray Zone

 When Sport Becomes Signal: Beyond the Handshake

When Sport Becomes Signal: Beyond the Handshake

In Depth

CCTVs In Police Station: Shield Against Abuse Of Power & Corruption

CCTVs In Police Station: Shield Against Abuse Of Power & Corruption

Editor's Pick

India Cannot Afford Delay: The NCW Is Right To Demand Stronger Laws Against Online Grooming

India Cannot Afford Delay: The NCW Is Right To Demand Stronger Laws Against Online Grooming
© 2014 India Commentary. All rights reserved.