By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2026-11-17 15:39:24
The Supreme Court has the power to suspend a life sentence pending appeal. It used that power for two convicts in the Bilkis Bano case. But the order does not explain why the circumstances justified this extraordinary relief. It is three substantive pages long, and its reasoning leaves important questions unanswered.
Start with what the order does. On 28 October, the Court suspended the sentences of Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi and Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya. It cited more than 17 years in custody, the severe handicap of one appellant, and the issues the appeals raise. Bail terms were left to the trial court. Bilkis Bano says she learnt of the order from press reports.
This is not a reversal of the January 2024 judgment. That ruling quashed the Gujarat government's remission orders because Gujarat lacked jurisdiction. It did not disturb the convictions. The convicts went back to prison to serve the sentences a Mumbai special court imposed in 2008. Suspension of sentence pending appeal is a separate power with a separate test. Both rulings can stand together.
That is where the defence of the order ends. The order gives reasons: incarceration, disability and pending issues. The criticism is that it does not explain the weight given to each.
The first omission is procedural. The convicts had already challenged the Bombay High Court's May 2017 judgment in the Supreme Court. Their special leave petitions were dismissed in July and November 2017. The present proceedings are fresh special leave petitions challenging the same judgment. The Court granted leave on 28 October 2026, converting them into appeals. The order does not say why these fresh challenges were entertained after the earlier dismissals. That may be lawful. But finality matters in criminal law, and successive litigation against the same conviction needs a stated ground. The Court has given none.
The second omission is the custody record. The order relies on more than 17 years of incarceration. The Gujarat government's affidavit, as reported, shows that Joshi spent 1,079 days on parole and furlough and Modhiya 1,234 days. Both also stayed out under the remission orders between August 2022 and January 2024, orders the Court later quashed. Parole or remission does not disqualify anyone from bail. But prolonged incarceration cannot be assessed without the full custodial record. The Court must explain how it assessed the custodial history, including the periods spent outside prison on parole, furlough and remission.
The third omission is the reasoning itself. The order does not describe the nature or medical effect of the disability. It does not say why the circumstances justified suspending the sentences of both men. It does not show how the gravity of the offences, gang rape and the murder of seven members of a family, was weighed against the time served. It does not address the earlier dismissals or the parole and remission periods. A suspension of sentence in a case of this gravity needs reasons that a reader can test. A bare conclusion cannot be tested.
The fourth issue is the victim. Bano says this is the second time an order has been passed without calling or hearing her. Her lawyer, Shobha Gupta, has said she will challenge it. In Jagjeet Singh v. Ashish Mishra (2022), the Court held that a victim who comes forward to participate in criminal proceedings must receive a fair and effective hearing, including when bail is reconsidered. Whether that ruling governs a suspension of sentence after a High Court has upheld the conviction is a question the Court must answer. The argument that it does is strong. If Bano was not notified, the Court should say why, and if she was, it should say so on the record.
The order records that the prosecution vehemently opposed the pleas. That does not make the order wrong. It does remind the Court that in this very case it once found the Gujarat government complicit in an unlawful remission. A case with that history requires a higher standard of explanation, not a lower one.
What should happen now? The Court should hear Bano's challenge promptly and on merits. It should publish a reasoned account covering the points above. The trial court should fix strict conditions, including limits on residence and a bar on contact with the victim's family. Bano has said she fears for her family's safety. That fear deserves a direct answer.
A court that sets aside an unlawful remission cannot be seen to release the same convicts without explanation. The Court has the power. It must now show the reasoning that justifies it.









