oppn parties Housing Societies Are Not Businesses: Time to Overhaul GST on Maintenance Charges

News Snippets

  • Congress leader Rahul Gandhi accused the BJP government of weakening India's democratic institutions and argued that India was becoming a marginal player in global affairs. The BJP rejected his remarks as misleading and damaging to India's international standing, renewing the political confrontation over his criticism of the government while speaking abroad
  • Political groups in Ladakh opposed the timing of the proposed panchayat, urban local body and Ladakh Autonomous Hill Development Council elections, arguing that winter migration could affect participation. The groups, which have been negotiating with the Centre, said a substantial section of the population leaves the region during winter, making the proposed electoral timetable unsuitable
  • The Supreme Court quashed the acquisition of mining land in Odisha's tribal region, reiterating that Gram Sabha consent is mandatory where statutory protections for tribal communities apply. The ruling reinforces the legal safeguards governing land acquisition and the rights of tribal communities affected by development projects
  • The Supreme Court said it would take up final hearings in December on petitions challenging the marital rape exception retained in the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita. The petitions question whether a husband should remain exempt from prosecution for rape when he forces his adult wife to have sexual intercourse against her consent
  • Odisha intensified evacuation and disaster-management operations as severe cyclonic storm Akvan approached the eastern coast, with thousands of residents moved to shelters and schools closed in vulnerable districts. The India Meteorological Department forecast landfall between Narsapur in Andhra Pradesh and Puri in Odisha around noon on November 20, with sustained winds of 90-100 kmph and gusts reaching 110 kmph
  • Indian Railways revised its bulk-ticket booking rules, removing the existing cap on the number of berths that could be booked for group reservations. The change is intended to make group travel easier, particularly for institutions, organisations and large travelling parties
  • India and Japan agreed to deepen defence cooperation, including through an arrangement allowing Japan's Self-Defence Forces to conduct live-fire training at Indian firing ranges for the first time
  • Prime Minister Narendra Modi urged Indian industry to increase domestic manufacturing, value addition and exports rather than remain dependent on the domestic market. Addressing FICCI's centenary annual general meeting, he identified pharmaceuticals, steel, aluminium, agriculture and engineering as sectors where India could reduce import dependence, while asking companies to translate tax concessions and economic reforms into greater investment and employment
  • Indian equity markets staged a strong recovery on Thursday, with the Sensex gaining 989.94 points, or 1.21 per cent, to close at 83,021.75 and the Nifty 50 rising 286.35 points, or 1.14 per cent, to 25,514.30
  • Insurance regulator IRDAI chairman Ajay Seth flagged potential conflicts of interest when banks sell insurance products and automobile dealers combine insurance distribution with vehicle repair services
  • India's men's hockey team began its campaign at the India-New Zealand Century of Sporting Unity event with a 3-2 victory over the hosts in Auckland. New Zealand took an early lead, but India fought back to secure the opening win
  • India defeated Malaysia 4-1 in the Women's Asian Hockey Champions Trophy in Bhopal, with Khan Mumtaz, captain Salima Tete, Pooja Sahu and Lalremsiami scoring a goal each
  • Indian men's doubles pair Satwiksairaj Rankireddy and Chirag Shetty entered the quarter-finals of the Hong Kong Open Super 500 after defeating Malaysia's Nur Mohd Azriyn Ayub and Tan Wee Kiong 21-19, 21-16
  • New Zealand reached 243 for five at stumps on the opening day of the first Test against India in Wellington, with Henry Nicholls scoring an unbeaten century and sharing a 173-run partnership with Glenn Phillips. India's bowlers had initially reduced the hosts to a precarious position before the middle-order recovery shifted the day's momentum towards New Zealand.
  • Leader of Opposition Rahul Gandhi told an interaction at Columbia University that India was sitting on an economic disaster, citing unemployment, weaknesses in the education system and the lack of career prospects for young people. The BJP accused him of running an anti-India campaign abroad, while Congress spokesperson Pawan Khera said the government appeared more concerned about Gandhi discussing economic problems than addressing them
The Ganga water treaty between India and Bangladesh is at risk of lapsing as strained relarions between neighbours have not led to talks about its renewal
oppn parties
Housing Societies Are Not Businesses: Time to Overhaul GST on Maintenance Charges

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2026-11-20 03:18:41

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator. Author of Cyber Scams in India, Digital Arrest, The Money Trap and The Human Hack

A resident paying Rs 9,000 a month for guards, lifts and water pumps ends up with a bill of Rs 10,620. The GST Council must separate essential residential upkeep from luxury amenities, and index the exemption limits to reality.

Consider a flat owner whose society charges Rs 9,000 a month. The money pays for security guards, housekeeping, lift servicing, water pumps, the generator and fire-safety equipment. There is no clubhouse and no swimming pool. If the society's annual aggregate turnover from supplies crosses Rs 20 lakh, and the entire Rs 9,000 is the taxable maintenance contribution, the bill attracts Rs 1,620 in GST, taking the monthly payment to Rs 10,620. That is the arithmetic behind a grievance that residents' associations across the country have been voicing, and it deserves far more attention from the GST Council than it has received.

What the rule actually says

The law is widely misunderstood, so it is worth stating precisely. Two separate rules operate here. First, a society whose aggregate annual turnover is Rs 20 lakh or less (Rs 10 lakh in the states where the lower registration threshold applies) is not required to register, and so does not collect GST on maintenance charges, even if individual contributions exceed Rs 7,500. Second, contributions of up to Rs 7,500 per member per month are exempt. GST on a member's contribution therefore becomes payable only when both conditions are met together: the society's turnover is above the registration threshold and the contribution exceeds Rs 7,500 per member per month. When both are met, CBIC Circular No. 109/28/2019-GST of July 2019 says that tax is payable on the entire contribution, not merely on the amount above Rs 7,500. On Rs 9,000, that means 18% on Rs 9,000, not on Rs 1,500.

The interpretation has also been contested in court. In July 2021, a single-judge bench of the Madras High Court, in Greenwood Owners Association v. Union of India, held that only the contribution exceeding Rs 7,500 should be taxable. The Union government appealed, and a division bench stayed the relevant portion of that judgment on 7 October 2021. The appeal remains pending, leaving the controversy unresolved. The CBIC's 2019 clarification therefore remains an important part of the existing administrative position. The episode nevertheless exposes the ambiguity and controversy surrounding a threshold that urgently needs reconsideration.

A limit frozen in time

The Rs 7,500 limit was raised from Rs 5,000 in January 2018. Nearly nine years on, it stands unchanged. Over the same period, the cost of running a residential complex has climbed steadily. Wages for guards and housekeeping staff, electricity tariffs, spare parts, insurance, audit and professional fees have all increased. The Rs 7,500 threshold has consequently lost much of its purchasing power. A modest complex can now collect more than Rs 7,500 per flat simply to keep essential services running. Crossing the threshold is no longer necessarily a sign of luxury. It may simply reflect inflation.

A housing society is not a commercial enterprise

A business collects revenue to earn a profit. A housing society pools its members' money to pay the security agency, the lift contractor, the electrician and the plumber. Whatever is collected is spent on the common property of the people who paid it.

It would be dishonest to pretend the law ignores this question. Under GST, an association supplying services to its members is treated as a supplier, and that is the legal starting point. But the Council has the power to exempt supplies in the public interest. The real question is one of policy: should a member-based body that maintains the common property of homes be taxed as though it were selling services in a market? Maintenance contributions are not discretionary consumption. They are what residents must pay to keep a building safe, clean and habitable.

A three-tier framework

Not all societies are alike, and the tax treatment should not pretend otherwise. The Council should consider three tiers.

Tier one: basic residential societies. Societies whose activities are confined to upkeep of common residential infrastructure should get a complete exemption on routine maintenance contributions, irrespective of the monthly and annual thresholds. The test must be written into the notification so that it does not invite litigation. For instance, a society would qualify if it runs no paid-use clubhouse, pool, gym or banquet facility and if commercial or amenity receipts form only a small share of its total collections, the share to be fixed by the Council. A small community hall used occasionally by residents should not disqualify a society.

Tier two: other residential societies. These provide some facilities beyond the basics but are not luxury establishments. For them, the monthly exemption should rise from Rs 7,500 to Rs 15,000 per flat. The annual figure should rise from Rs 20 lakh to Rs 50 lakh through a special exemption or registration framework for qualifying housing associations. The Council should design this framework to preserve the applicable GST treatment of independently supplied commercial services without imposing unnecessary compliance obligations on residential maintenance activities. The general registration limit for other service providers would stay untouched. The two changes must go together, since a higher monthly limit without a higher annual limit leaves smaller societies exposed, and the reverse does not help residents paying more than Rs 7,500. The Rs 15,000 figure reflects the faster rise in labour, power and service costs that societies actually bear.

Tier three: premium and commercial services. Where a society independently supplies identifiable commercial or premium recreational services for consideration, those supplies should be taxed in accordance with the applicable GST provisions, with proper accounting and input tax credit.

Complexes with shops and offices

Residential-cum-commercial complexes share a managing body and infrastructure, but their members are in different tax positions. The presence of shops should not strip residential members of an exemption they would otherwise get. The Council should require separate accounting for residential and commercial contributions, and issue a national clarification so that the treatment does not vary from state to state and from auditor to auditor. The treatment of sinking funds, corpus contributions and other special collections needs the same clarity.

The objections, and answers to them

Three objections deserve a direct answer.

Revenue. The principal fiscal objection will be the potential loss of revenue. The Finance Ministry should publish an estimate of the revenue implications, including the effect of reduced input tax credit claims. Such an assessment would allow the Council to weigh the fiscal cost against the relief provided to millions of urban households.

Input tax credit. A fully exempt society cannot claim credit on the GST its vendors charge on security, housekeeping and lift contracts. Some of the saving will therefore be eaten up, and residents will not see a full 18% reduction. That is a real trade-off. The Council should examine whether a suitable mechanism can be provided for societies that would prefer to remain under the regular taxation regime, subject to the applicable input tax credit rules.

Abuse. An exemption invites disguised commercial activity, such as renting out the clubhouse or selling advertising space inside the complex. That is why every tier must come with transparent accounts, separate treatment of commercial receipts, rental income and advertising revenue, and a disclosure of how maintenance contributions are used.

Review it every three years

The lasting failure of the present rule is that it was never indexed. The Council should build an inflation-linked review of all limits every three years, so that the next generation of residents is not left to petition the Council over a number set in 2018.

Rational taxation, not exemption without accountability

This is not an argument against taxing housing societies. It is an argument for tax that recognises what a society is. The proposal is simple: a complete exemption for routine maintenance in basic residential societies; Rs 15,000 per flat and a special Rs 50 lakh annual registration threshold for other qualifying societies; GST on genuinely commercial and premium supplies; separate accounts in mixed complexes; and a periodic, inflation-linked review.

Residents should not pay 18% on top of their maintenance simply because the cost of keeping their homes safe, clean and functional has gone up. The Council should take this up on priority.