By Our Editorial Team
First publised on 2026-11-20 14:44:10
The Supreme Court has done what India's river programmes have avoided for decades. In its order of November 4, a bench of Justices Manoj Misra and Manmohan held every state, Union Territory and district accountable if the Yamuna's quality deteriorates on any parameter while passing through or leaving its jurisdiction. The CPCB must propose a formula for the fine, which goes to the Court's Registry. States may recover it from polluters and negligent officials, but only after an inquiry. That condition is fair, and it means penalties must rest on evidence.
The diagnosis is blunt. Pollution has risen despite huge spending, with 520 drains discharging into the river. The Yamuna Action Plan says 28 of Delhi's 37 sewage treatment plants meet standards. The CPCB says none meets all of them. The Court's answer is measurement. Plants must install tamper-proof smart meters within a month and upload discharge data live. A break in the feed exceeding 24 hours will be presumed to mean the plant is not operating unless the operator proves otherwise. Large plants face unannounced quarterly sampling by independent laboratories, with results published within 30 days, and named officers must file monthly affidavits.
The Ganga explains why this matters. Namami Gange has disbursed Rs 21,340 crore since 2014, of which Rs 16,025.97 crore went to sewage projects. It has built substantial infrastructure and institutional mechanisms, including performance-linked hybrid annuity contracts and one-city-one-operator arrangements. Treatment capacity reached 4,263 MLD by June 2026, against 6,610 MLD planned. Yet the CPCB's February 2025 report to the National Green Tribunal recorded an individual faecal coliform reading of 33,000 MPN per 100 ml at Deeha Ghat, against a bathing-water criterion of 2,500, during the Maha Kumbh. The Board's own later report of February 28 found that median readings were within the prescribed criteria. That the Board's verdict turned on medians rather than individual readings is itself the case for live, plant-level data. The lesson is clear. Capacity creation and expenditure cannot be treated as proof of a clean river. What matters is independently verified performance at the point of discharge, transparent disclosure and consequences for non-compliance.
Two tests remain. The formula must be heavy and prompt enough to change behaviour. Separately, the Court has directed environmental compensation from treatment plant operators for every day of non-compliance. That provision must be enforced without dilution. The Court's insistence that removal of riverbed colonies follow rehabilitation must also be honoured, or restoration will become a humanitarian crisis. The matter returns on January 13, 2027. The bench has left administrators room to act while making them answerable for results. Governments must now show that they will pay when the numbers say they failed.








