By Our Editorial Team
First publised on 2026-11-17 10:32:57
The Supreme Court has suspended the life sentences of two Bilkis Bano case convicts and granted them bail. The power exists. But the order does not explain why the circumstances justified this extraordinary relief. It is three substantive pages long, and its reasoning leaves important questions unanswered.
This is not a reversal of the January 2024 ruling. That judgment quashed remission because Gujarat lacked jurisdiction. It left the convictions intact. The present proceedings are fresh special leave petitions challenging the same May 2017 Bombay High Court judgment. The Court granted leave on 28 October 2026, converting them into appeals. It cited over 17 years in custody, one appellant's severe handicap, and the issues the appeals raise. The prosecution vehemently opposed the pleas.
The order does not say why fresh challenges were entertained after the convicts' earlier petitions were dismissed in 2017. It does not explain how it assessed the custodial history, including the periods spent outside prison on parole, furlough and remission. The Gujarat government's affidavit, as reported, records 1,079 days of parole and furlough for Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi and 1,234 days for Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya. Both also benefited from remission between August 2022 and January 2024. Nor does the order describe the disability or weigh the gravity of the offences against the time served.
The victim's role is the other open question. Bilkis Bano says she was not called or heard and learnt of the order from the press. In Jagjeet Singh v. Ashish Mishra (2022), the Court held that a victim who comes forward to participate must receive a fair and effective hearing. Whether that principle applies here is a question the Court must answer on the record.
The Court should hear Bano's challenge promptly, state whether she was served, and publish full reasons. The trial court should set strict conditions that protect her and her family. A sentence for gang rape and murder should not be suspended without a reasoned order that the public can examine.









