By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2026-11-16 07:47:47
A grandson cannot claim his grandfather's property while his father lives and is himself an heir. The Supreme Court has said so plainly. The ruling closes a door that many Hindu families have long assumed was open.
The case is J. Rajesh (Minor) through J. Gomathi v. M. Kumaran (Dead) through LRs, Civil Appeal No. 7020 of 2012, reported as 2026 INSC 1208. Justices Augustine George Masih and Sunita Agarwal decided it on 6 November 2026. Justice Agarwal wrote the judgment.
The facts are simple. N Ramakrishnan's property was divided among his heirs after his daughter filed a partition suit in 1993. His son, M Kumaran, received a plot under a compromise deed in February 1994. He sold it in April 1997. Kumaran's son, Rajesh, sued in 1997 through his mother. He was a minor. He said the plot was ancestral and that he had acquired a coparcenary interest in it by birth.
The suit had a weakness at its root. It was filed while his father was alive. It did not challenge the partition decree or the sale deeds. It asked a court to treat a divided share as an undivided one.
Three courts disagreed with him on that point. The appellate court set aside the trial court's preliminary decree for partition. The Madras High Court upheld that. The Supreme Court upheld it too.
The reasoning rests on the Hindu Succession Act of 1956. When a Hindu male dies without a will, Section 8 sends his property first to Class I heirs. These include his son, daughter, widow and mother. The son of a predeceased son is in that class. The son of a living son is not. Rajesh's father was alive. Rajesh was therefore outside the class that inherits.
The bench added a second point. The old right of a son's son in his grandfather's property during his father's lifetime existed under personal Hindu law before 1956. The legislature did not expressly save it when it enacted the Act. That silence matters. Parliament chose a statutory scheme of succession. Courts cannot revive a claim that Parliament left out.
The Court also relied on its own line of decisions, including Commissioner of Wealth Tax v. Chander Sen. The principle is settled. A son who takes property from his intestate father under Section 8 holds it as an absolute owner. It does not become joint family property in his hands merely because he has a son.
Partition settled the rest. Under Section 19, heirs who take an intestate's property hold it as tenants in common. Each holds an individual share. Each can deal with it independently. Once the heirs partitioned, the joint coparcenary did not continue. The plot became Kumaran's exclusive property. He was entitled to sell it.
Rajesh also leaned on Section 29-A, inserted by the Tamil Nadu Amendment of 1989 to give daughters coparcenary rights. The Court rejected that argument. Succession had opened on the grandfather's death. That was before Rajesh was born and before the 1993 suit. He was not a surviving coparcener when it opened.
There is a lesson here for families. Many assume that a grandson steps into the property by birth. That assumption fails once succession has opened and the estate has been divided. The grandfather's death, the partition and the allotment each close off the claim.
There is a lesson for buyers as well. A purchaser who buys a share allotted under a partition or compromise deed can rely on the owner's title. A rule that let every grandson reopen old partitions would unsettle titles across the country. Land records are already contested enough.
The ruling also shows how much depends on which school of Hindu law applies. Mitakshara gives a son an interest in ancestral coparcenary property by birth. Dayabhaga, which governs West Bengal and Assam, does not. Under Dayabhaga, the son's right opens only on the father's death. Until then the father owns the property and can deal with it as he chooses. Readers in Bengal should note the difference.
The verdict is correct in law. It is also fair in outcome. A father who receives property under a partition owns it. He may sell it, gift it or leave it by will. His son has a hope of inheriting. He does not have a right to interfere.
Families should still plan. A will removes doubt. A clear partition deed records who owns what. Rajesh's suit was filed in 1997. It took 29 years to reach a final answer, and his father died along the way, leaving the appeal to be defended by his legal representatives. Clear documents are cheaper than long litigation.










