oppn parties EC's Musical Chairs In Bengal: Newly-Appointed DGP Replaced Within 24 Hours

Story Of The Day

Swati Maliwal Incident: How To People Like Bibhav Kumar Get The Power To Do Such Things?
OPINIONS : Strongly Expressed

May 19, 2024

People Are Talking About

Rohit Warns Sarfaraz, Police Use It To Warn Two-Wheeler Riders

News Snippets

  • AAP changes track, says Swati maliwal acting at BJPs behest, denies charge that she was assaulted at Arvind Kejriwal's residence
  • In Rae Bareli, Sonia Gandhi says she is "handing over my son Raqhul to you" in a bid to win votes for him
  • Prime Minister Modi says Congress-SP will run the bulldozer over ram Mandir in Ayodhya if elected
  • ED claims it has found a recording of Kejriwal speaking to a hawala operator
  • ED names Arvind Kejriwal and AAP as accused in fresh chargesheet in liqwuor excise case
  • SC says courts should hear bail petitions speedily as 'every day counts'
  • Supreme Court asks Election Commission to explain increase in voting percentage days after polling, seeks reply by May 24
  • Trai to issue consultation paper to curb pesky calls
  • Insolvency and Bankruptcy Borad of India has found in a study that if resolution is delayed, recovery drops and there is 49% recovery if resolved within 330 days and if resolution is delayed beyond 600 days, it drops to 26%
  • Stocks continue to recover on Friday: Sensex adds 253 points to 73917 while Nifty gains 62 points to 22466
  • Elorda Cup boxing: Disastrous day for India as all four male bozers lose their semifinal bouts to end with bronze medals
  • Olympic-bound boxer Parveen Hooda banned by ITA for not disclosing her whereabouts.
  • Thailand Open badminton: Satwik-Chirag reach semifinals
  • IPL: LSG beat MI by 18 runs as Pooran scores a blistering 75 off just 29 balls but both teams are out of playoff contention
  • Another woman alleges rape in Sandeshkhali, FIR lodged against 5 persons including 2 TMC functionaries
Supreme Court says no exception was made in granting interim bail to Arvind Kejriwal
oppn parties
EC's Musical Chairs In Bengal: Newly-Appointed DGP Replaced Within 24 Hours

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2024-03-20 03:51:54

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator.

The Election Commission (EC) on Tuesday replaced Vivek Sahay, whom it had appointed just a day ago, as Director General of Police of West Bengal (after replacing incumbent Rajeev Kumar) and appointed Sanjay Mukherjee in his place. Sahay created history by becoming the DGP for the shortest period ever. Although the EC did not give any reasons for the change, it is being reported that since Sahay was to retire in May in the middle of the elections, the EC thought it fit to affect the change now instead of in the middle of the elections.

But whatever the reason, this double-change in two days shows the EC in poor light. Why did it appoint Sahay in the first place when his retirement was to take place in the middle of the elections? Did it not scrutinize the profile of the officer with a fine tooth-comb? It is extremely bad on EC's part to have appointed Sahay the DGP and then remove him just a day later. The EC is guilty of arbitrariness and the Trinamool Congress (TMC) has slammed the body for the same and also questioned its neutrality.

Although Sahay could have been given an extension till the results were declared but that would have gone against the EC's stated policy of not allotting election work to police officers on extension. In 2014, before the general elections, the EC had directed all states not to give election duty to any police officers who had retired and were on extension.

In Sahay's case, the EC committed a blunder by not taking into account his retirement date before appointing him in place of Rajeev Kumar. The decision to replace him in a day has left it open to charges of bias and the TMC has alleged that the BJP is turning the EC into an extended arm of the party. It has demanded Supreme Court-monitored Lok Sabha elections in the state. 

Other Stories You Make Like

Editorials

Bail To Prabir Purkayastha: Supreme Court Bats For Due Process

Bail To Prabir Purkayastha: Supreme Court Bats For Due Process

 Prajwal Revanna: History Of Sexual Offences Comes To Light

Prajwal Revanna: History Of Sexual Offences Comes To Light

In Depth

Arvind Kejriwal Returns Without Losing His Form

Arvind Kejriwal Returns Without Losing His Form

Editor's Pick

The BJP Crushes The Opposition By Any & All Means

The BJP Crushes The Opposition By Any & All Means
© 2014 India Commentary. All rights reserved.