oppn parties Mirzya is Director Mehra's Failure

News Snippets

  • UP government removed Lokesh M as CEO of Noida Authority and formed a SIT to inquire into the death of techie Yuvraj Mehta who drowned after his car fell into a waterlogged trench at a commercial site
  • Nitin Nabin elected BJP President unopposed, will take over today
  • Supreme Court rules that abusive language against SC/ST persons cannot be construed an offence under the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act
  • Orissa HC dismissed the pension cliams of 2nd wife citing monogamy in Hindu law
  • Delhi HC quashed the I-T notices to NDTV founders and directed the department to pay ₹ 2 lakh to them for 'harassment'
  • Bangladesh allows Chinese envoy to go near Chicken's Nest, ostensibly to see the Teesta project
  • Kishtwar encounter: Special forces jawan killed, 7 others injured in a faceoff with terrorists
  • PM Modi, in a special gesture, receives UAE President Md Bin Zayed Al Nahyan at the airport. India, UAE will boost strategic defence ties
  • EAM S Jaishankar tells Poland to stop backing Pak-backed terror in India. Also, Polish minister walks off a talk show when questioned on cross-border terrorism
  • Indigo likely to cut more flights after Feb 10 when the new flight rules kick in for it
  • Supreme Court asks EC to publish the names of all voters with 'logical discrepency' in th Bengal SIR
  • ICC has asked Bangladesh to decide by Jan 21 whether they will play in India or risk removal from the tournament. Meanwhile, as per reports, Pakistan is likely to withdraw if Bangladesh do not play
  • Tata Steel Masters Chess: Pragg loses again, Gukesh settles for a draw
  • WPL: RCB win their 5th consecutive game by beating Gujarat Giants by 61 runs, seal the playoff spot
  • Central Information Commission (CIC) bars lawyers from filing RTI applications for knowing details of cases they are fighting for their clients as it violates a Madras HC order that states that such RTIs defeat the law's core objectives
Stocks slump on Tuesday even as gold and silver toucvh new highs /////// Government advises kin of Indian officials in Bangladesh to return home
oppn parties
Mirzya is Director Mehra's Failure

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2016-10-10 22:14:11

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator.
Saw Mirzya. Was left cold. When a director over indulges himself, he forgets storytelling and loses control over his craft. If content is king and if Rakesh Omprakash Mehra thought he had great content in juxtaposing Mirza-Sahiban with modern day Adil-Suchitra, he started going wrong when he thought frames would compensate for narration. The film drags and the viewer loses interest. It becomes difficult to believe that the same director gave us Rang De Basanti.

The male debutante of the film, Harshavardhan Kapoor has taken to Instagram to say that “whenever you try and build a new path by not doing the conventional thing, people will take time to see and recognise it, first they will bring u down then they will eventually buy you drinks , but I only drink the best whisky so be ready that time will come , once an artist always an artist.” This shows that he has taken failure badly.

But Mirzya is not the failure of Harshavardhan Kapoor (although it will count as one in his filmography). Neither is it one for the other debutante Saiyami Kher. Or for that matter any of the other actors. It is the failure of the director. You can personally feel that you have done an avant garde job by jumping back and forth between two periods, but when it starts irritating the viewer, you have not done your job judiciously. The same thing has been done in a much better w+ay by others in the past. The trouble with Mehra is that he takes his job too seriously. It will help if he loosens up a bit.

Harshavardhan and Saiyami can hold their heads high though. Despite a bad product, they shone brightly. One could make out that they were held back by the director’s vision. Saiyami, particularly, shows a free spirit that can take her very far. Harshvardhan, on the other hand, shows much intensity, but has to take care that he does not traverse the path taken by Abhishek Bachchan. A few wrong choices can spoil it for him, like they did for Bachchan, despite an equally intense performance in his debut film, Refugee.