oppn parties Should the Movie PK be Banned?

News Snippets

  • Uttarakhand HC says marital discord, suspicion and quarrels cannot be held to be abetment of suicide
  • Two sisters, both brides-to-be, died by suspected suicide in Jodhpur. No suicide note was found
  • RTI reveals that 200 big cats were poached in India between 2005 and 2025, with the most in MP
  • After the US Supreme Court order on tariffs, Centre has put Indian trade team's US visit on hold
  • Delhi Police bust terror module linked to Lashkar that was plotting to strike in Delhi. Arrest 7 Bangladeshis with Aadhar IDs
  • PM Modi announced in his Mann Ki Baat that Edwin Lutyens' statue will be replaced with that of C Rajagopalchari at the Rashtrapati Bhawan
  • Facial recognition at Digi Yatra gates in Kolkata Airport suffered prolonged glitch on Sunday, forcing passengers to wait in long queues
  • Ranji Final: Strong Karnataka take on rising J&K in the match starting from Tuesday
  • Rising Stars women's cricket: India 'A' beat Bangladesh by 46 runs to capture title
  • Super 8s: Co-hosts Sri Lanka lose too, England beat them by 51 runs
  • Super 8s: South Africa crush India by 76 runs as nothing goes right for the hosts
  • PM Modi inaugurates India's fastest metro in Meerut and the first Vande Bharat sleeper in Bengal, This sleeper will cover Howrah to Guwahati route
  • After his consecutive failures, Abhishek Sharma has created a problem for the team management: should they give him one more chance in a vital match today or go for Sanju Samson as opener
  • A Pocso court in Prayagraj ordered an FIR against Swami Avi Mukteshawaranand and his disciple Muktanand Giri for molesting underage boys in their Magh Mela camp
  • TOI reported that while private universities filed more patents, elite institutions like IIT and IISc got more approvals between 2020-2025
T20 World Cup Super 8s: India get a reality check, outplayed by South Africa in their first match, end 12-match winning streak
oppn parties
Should the Movie PK be Banned?

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2014-12-30 20:03:22

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator.
Have you seen the movie PK? If you are Hindu, do you find anything offensive in it to the extent that you would go about calling for a ban on it? I do not think any rational Hindu would find it offensive and call for a ban. Yet, there are mobs in Ahmedabad, Bhopal and may other places in India who are trying to stall the shows by creating nuisance at theatres screening the movie. They are creating an atmosphere of fear in the minds of the general public and at the same time giving a handle to the Hindu organizations to call for a complete ban on the movie. This is an age old practice: in India, a work of art can only be banned if it is perceived to be a threat to public peace and can cause enmity between communities. So first create an atmosphere where public peace is disturbed and communities can go to war (after all, the main protagonist in the movie is played by Aamir Khan and how can a Muslim make fun of, and question, Hindu babas and rituals? It is beyond their combined IQ levels to understand that the writer/director is a Hindu and the person raising the pertinent questions in the movie is an alien coming from outer space, as if that matters.).

It is shameful that a film made with due care and with family audiences in mind, a film certified to be fit for universal viewing by the Censor Board in India and a film getting both critical and audience acclaim is being made the subject of unnecessary controversy. As I have said time and again, banning books, speeches or films, or any work of art for that matter, does not solve anything. Acharya Rajnish had rightly said â€Å"a dagger should not be the response to my views”(â€Å"meri baton ka jawab chaku nahin hain”). So also bans or disruptions should not be the response to works of art. A handful of people should not be allowed to create an atmosphere that can lead to a ban. Instead, they should be arrested and dealt with firmly. The government should send out a signal that the views of crores of its citizens who have seen and appreciated the movie would be respected and a small band of dissenters will not have their way.

If these unruly elements see the box office figures of PK, they and their nationwide cousins should realize that their efforts are counter-productive. PK is well on its way to become the highest Bollywood grosser of all times in the shortest possible time. While most of it is due to its near perfect story-telling, flawless acting and entertainment value, some of it must also be due to the antics of these mobs which must have sent viewers scrambling for seats, lest the film be banned.