oppn parties What is Srijato Bandopadhyay's Fault?

News Snippets

  • In reply to a question in Parliament, the government says it is empowered to lawfully intercept, monitor or decrpyt information stored in a computer resource in the interest of sovereignty or integrity of India
  • Police stop a 12-year old girl on her way to the Sabarimala shrine
  • In Karnataka, the JD(S) indicates that it might support the BJP government if it falls short of numbers after the bypolls
  • Congress pips the BJP in local body elections in Rajasthan, winning 961 wards to the BJPs 737
  • After Airtel and Vodafone-Idea, Jio also indicates that tariffs will be raised from December
  • Sources in Shiv Sena say that they might revive the alliance with the BJP if it offers the 50:50 deal
  • A miffed Sanjay Rout of the Shiv Sena says that it will take "100 births" to understand Sharad Pawar
  • Mobile operators Vodafone-Idea and Airtel decide to raise tariffs from next month
  • Sharad Pawar meets Sonia Gandhi and says more time needed for government formation in Maharashtra
  • Justice S A Bobde sworn in as the 47th Chief Justice of India
  • Supreme Court holds hotels liable for theft of vehicle from their parking area if parked by valet, says "owner's risk" clause is not a shield from such liability
  • Finance Minister says she is receiving feedback from many sectors that recovery is happening as there is lower stress
  • Sabarimala temple opens, but police bar the entry of women below 50 years
  • Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman says Air India and BPCL to be sold off by March
  • Media person Rajat Sharma resigns as DDCA president
Two Muslim litigants in Ayodhya refuse to accept the Supreme Court order, say review petition might be filed
oppn parties
What is Srijato Bandopadhyay's Fault?

By Sunil Garodia

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator. Writes for a number of publications.
Bangla poet Srijato Bandopadhyay posted a short poem on his Facebook wall. It was his innermost feeling on how religion was becoming all important and how a hermit had become the king in UP after Yogi Adityanath became the CM of the state. Not a single line in the poem denigrates any religion or offends religious feelings of Hindus. It is just a poet’s wail which points out the injustice in religion getting involved in governance and imposing a particular set of beliefs in a state that has numerous religions that follow different beliefs. It is by no means a call for action. It is just an expression of what the poet felt. It cannot be taken as something written to disturb communal peace or cause disturbance amongst communities.

Yet, Arnab Sarkar, a member of the unheard of organization Hindu Samhati has filed a police complaint against Srijato, invoking Sec. 295 (A) of the IPC and Sec. 67 of the IT Act, with the cyber cell of Siliguri police in northern West Bengal. The IPC section is for deliberate and malicious acts, intended to outrage religious feelings. The charges are non-bailable and non-compoundable. Police can arrest Srijato without a warrant. If prosecuted, Srijato faces up to three years in jail.

If there is something called an extreme and foolish reaction to a poem, this is it. Srijato Bandopadhyay is not a habitual pamphleteer. He does not have a history of denigrating the Hindu, or any other, religion as a matter of habit. His poetry takes a different route. This time, he was disturbed at the turn of events when he found someone who claimed to be a hermit, ostensibly surviving on alms, or bhikha, as the poem points out, become a king. He just penned his feelings about the happening. Perhaps the last two lines, where he talks about how the hermit will not be able to “rape” him as his “trishul” would be blunted by a “condom” is what got the goat of the complainant.

But poets have a way with words. Here, the poet just wanted to say that he is not afraid of the rise of fundamentalism as evinced by the assumption of government office by a hermit as he has insulated and shielded (hence, the use of “condom”)himself against any effort of the hermit to harm him. Rape, trishul and condom are words he chose to express that. If people have problems with it, it means that we will have no freedom of speech hereafter. Prime Minister Narendra Modi should warn people claiming to represent off shoots of Hindu organizations against filing unnecessary complaints to stifle free speech. We just celebrated the World Poetry Day. Even Modi professed to be a poet. At least he should then understand how a poet’s mind works and how and why he chooses to express his angst through words that have thousands of meanings other than the constricted religious ones assigned to them.

Bengal had already witnessed the crushing of freedom of speech when Taslima Nasreen was ordered out of the state in 2007 after a series of riots and curfews over her writings. Seizing upon that, BJP member and actor Locket Chatterjee has said that even Srijato Bandopadhyay should be prosecuted. Bengal had brought shame upon itself in the Taslima case. Should it invite it again now? Two wrongs will never make a right.

Picture courtesy: Facebook wall of Srijato Bandopadhyay