oppn parties Give Transgenders Their Legal Due, But Make Them Behave, Apply Criminal Laws to Them

News Snippets

  • Amit Panghal becomes first Indian male to win silver at the World Boxing Championships
  • "Gully Boy" to be India's entry for the Oscars
  • Rajeev Kumar called an "absconder" by the CBI
  • Alipore court refuses to grant anticipatory bail to Rajeev Kumar
  • Trump likely to sign a mini trade deal with India next week
  • Government planning a loan mela to cover 400 districts in two phases
  • PM Modi says Kashmiris need a hug from all Indians
  • NPA tag will not be put on any MSME till March 20
  • Government likely to announce another economic stimulus package today ahead of the GST Council meet in Goa
  • Air Marshall RKS Bhadauria, slated to retire just a few days from now, to be the next chief of IAF
  • PM Modi slams politicians from his own party who are making irresponsible statements on the Ayodhya case and tells them to wait for the Supreme Court order
  • Telecom panel says resident welfare associations (RWA) cannot give monopoly access to any one service provider and infrastructure in public spaces and residential complexes will have to be shared by all
  • Mamata Banerjee meets Amit Shah, tells him there is no need for an NRC in Bengal
  • After 14 days, there is no hope left for reviving Vikram, the moon lander
  • CBI teams search for elusive Rajeev Kumar
PM Modi to address more than 50000 people at the Howdy Modi event in Houston today where he will be joined by the US president Donald Trump
oppn parties
Give Transgenders Their Legal Due, But Make Them Behave, Apply Criminal Laws to Them

By Sunil Garodia

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator. Writes for a number of publications.
The Supreme Court rightly rapped the Centre over its prevarication in granting reservation benefits in education and government jobs to transgenders by making up excuses and seeking frivolous clarifications from the court despite its April 2014 ruling where the SC bench had clearly said that the wider meaning assigned to transgenders in society was not legally acceptable and gays, lesbians and bisexuals were excluded from the legal term transgenders.

Hence, it is deplorable that the Centre, instead of moving to implement the court’s directions in these two and half years, is still trying to seek clarifications. This move to buy time will not endear it to the transgender community, whose grievances are not misplaced. Neither will it show it in good light vis-à-vis accepting judicial decisions.

After the April 2014 judgment, the Centre should have moved to carry out a proper census of transgender people in the country. It should have allowed relief to them in education and jobs as directed by the SC bench. It should have made separate toilets for them at public places. Just having a column for the third sex in government forms is not a solution to their problems.

At the same time, if several rights, relief and quotas are granted to the transgenders, their habit of holding the society to ransom should also be made punishable. It is deplorable that transgenders take over street crossings in most towns and cities and aggressively accost car-owners to give them money. Their crude and insulting methods are criminal in nature and intrude on the privacy of others. They also take over local and long distance trains and force people to give them money. They create a lot of tamasha at child-births and weddings to demand huge sums of money. This is nothing but extortion on their part. The police do not register complaints against them and never take any action, often laughing and asking citizens to “settle” with them.

The standard excuse of transgenders is that no school admits them and no one gives them jobs. But with the Supreme Court giving them a separate legal identity that brings with it several benefits, they should now also be made to behave like normal citizens. If they demand money forcefully or if they gate crash private functions, they should be arrested as normal trespassers and punished accordingly. Their excesses should not be condoned now on account of them being different.