oppn parties Is Bhagwant Mann Being 'Remote-Controlled'?

News Snippets

  • Maharashtra cabinet is likely to bee expanded today with the Shiv Sena and the BJP equally sharing the new berths
  • Kapil Sibal says there is 'no hope left' in Supreme Court, slammed by law minister Kiren Rijiju
  • Centre tells Rajya Sabha that Bengal got zero MGNREGS payout this fiscal for not complying with Central directives
  • Monsoon session of Parliament ends 4 days early
  • Chess Olympiad: India A, comprising Tania Sachdev, Koneru Humoy and Bhakti, among others, look set to win gold
  • CWG: India's best ever perrformance with 22 golds, 16 silvers and 23 bronze medals and 4th position on the table
  • CWG: Sharath Kamal wins gold in men's singles in table tennis
  • CWG: Satwik-Chirag win gold in men's doubles in badminton
  • CWG: PV Sindhu wins gold in women's singles in badminton
  • CWG: Lakshya Sen wins gold in men's singles in badminton
  • Mamata Banerjee says states should not be forced to implement the NEP
  • PM Modi asks states to raise farm output
  • Differences between JD(U) and BJP in Bihar came to fore again as JD(U) chief Lalan Singh accused the BJP of repeating the Chirag Paswan model with RCP Singh
  • CWG: Lakhsya Sen and PV Sindhu enter finals in badminton while Sharath Kamal enters TT finals
  • CWG: Indian women lose to Australia by 9 runs in cricket to settle for silver
Nitish Kumar resigns as Bihar chief minister, breaks alliance with the BJP /////// Most likely will form the government in alliance with RJD, Congress and Left parties
oppn parties
Is Bhagwant Mann Being 'Remote-Controlled'?

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2022-07-13 08:41:32

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator.

The creation of a temporary advisory panel, led by AAP MP Raghav Chaddha, to assist Punjab chief minister Bhagwant Mann, is rightly being viewed by the opposition parties in the state as interference in the governance of the state by the party high command. The opposition, which was already charging that the Mann government was being 'remote-controlled' by the AAP high command (read: Arvind Kejriwal) from Delhi, have now started saying that with the appointment of the Chaddha panel, even the last vestige of independence has gone. 

While this might be wrong and the panel might have been appointed just to guide the Punjab government in putting in place the so-called 'Delhi model' to work in the state, the fact remains that such a thing could have been done at the party level without the need for a separate panel being formed specifically for the purpose to 'assist' the elected government. The formation of the panel sends wrong signals which might not go down well with the people. 

The supreme leaders of all regional or small political parties are known not to trust any other leaders in the party and hence are known not to give independent decision-making responsibility to them. Arvind Kejriwal is no different. Since AAP has national ambitions, it is very important for it to ensure that the 'Delhi model' is implemented properly and in full in Punjab and more importantly, it succeeds as it has in Delhi. Only then can the party tout it as the 'Kejriwal model' when it campaigns in other states.

But the problem is that if the high command does not let state leaders work independently and continuously breathes down their necks, it might work against it in other states. The opposition will be quick to seize upon the fact and campaign against AAP in other states on that basis. It is sad that despite always saying that it is different from other mainstream parties AAP is following in their footsteps by taking steps to centralize decision making at the high command level and not letting state government work independently.