oppn parties Do Not Support Pakistani Artistes Now

News Snippets

  • Justice Surya Kaqnt sworn in as the 53rd CJI. Says free speech needs to be strengthened
  • Plume originating from volacnic ash in Ehtiopia might delay flights in India today
  • Supreme Court drops the fraud case against the Sandesaras brothers after they agree to pay back Rs 5100 cr. It gives them time till Dec 17 to deposit the money. The court took pains to say that this order should not be seen as a precedent in such crimes.
  • Chinese authorities detain a woman from Arunachal Pradesh who was travelling with her Indian passport. India lodges strong protest
  • S&P predicts India's economy to grow at 6.5% in FY26
  • The December MPC meet of RBI may reduce rates as the nation has seen steaqdy growth with little or no inflation
  • World Boxing Cup Finals: Hitesh Gulia wins gold in 70kgs
  • Kabaddi World Cup: Indian Women win their second consecutive title at Dhaka, beating Taipei 35-28
  • Second Test versus South Africa: M Jansen destroys India as the hosts lose all hopes of squaring the series. India out for 201, conceding a lead of 288 runs which effectively means that South Africa are set to win the match and the series
  • Defence minister Rajnath Singh said that Sindh may be back in India
  • After its total rejection by voters in Bihar, the Congress high command said that it happened to to 'vote chori' by the NDA and forced elimination of voters in the SIR
  • Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA) fined a Patna cafe Rs 30000 for adding service charge on the bill of a customer after it was found that the billing software at the cafe was doing it for all patrons
  • Kolkata HC rules that the sewadars (managers) of a debuttar (Deity's) property need not take permission from the court for developing the property
  • Ministry of Home Affairs said that there were no plans to introduce a bill to change the status of Chandigarh in the ensuing winter session of Parliament
  • A 20-year-old escort and her agent were held in connection with the murder of a CA in a Kolkata hotel
Iconic actor Dharmendra is no more, cremated at Pawan Hans crematorium in Juhu, Mumbai
oppn parties
Do Not Support Pakistani Artistes Now

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2016-10-01 07:48:36

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator.
Salman Khan has also jumped on the wagon of supporters of Pakistani artistes working in India. All those indulging in this have some standard responses as follows:

1. Artistes are not terrorists
2. Banning artistes will not solve the problem
3. People to people contact with Pakistan should be maintained
4. The government has given them visa and allowed them to work
5. Talent from anywhere should be respected

No one is saying that artistes are terrorists. But they come from a country that is breeding and sending terrorists to India to cause destruction. It is not the fault of Pakistani artistes that their country is doing this. But they can at least condemn such attacks. Zee TV supremo and MP Subhash Chandra is on record as having said that he called up all Pakistani artistes working in India and asked them to condemn the Uri attack without naming Pakistan if they wished. But none of them did so. Now if their country of origin continues to kill our soldiers and citizens and if Pakistani artistes working in India do not have the sensitivity or the courage to even condemn these attacks, one think they have no business to earn their living here. Indian Motion Picture Producers’ Association (IMPPA) has already passed a resolution to ban them.

Artistes are said to be sensitive people. It is out of sensitivity that Indian artists are defending Pakistani artistes working in India. But by not condemning the frequent terrorist attacks on India, Pakistani artistes have shown they have no sensitivity left and are here only to earn better than what they can do in their own country. Another big reason for not allowing them to work in India is that the arrangement in not reciprocal – no Indian artist will ever be allowed to live and work freely in Pakistan. So why should we always display one-sided friendship. This makes us soft and spineless in the eyes of the Pakistani establishment. Further, it is also an insult to the martyrdom of our brave soldiers that we continue to pay absurd amounts to Pakistani artistes for ordinary work that can be done by any Indian artist and shower them with love and affection without any compelling reason other than commerce.

The Pakistani artistes working in India keep harping that they get immense love and affection anywhere they go in India. Indian artistes have also vouched that they get similar treatment in Pakistan. Then why are Pakistani artistes not in the forefront of building up public opinion in favour of India in their country. At least Indian artistes try to build public opinion in favour of Pakistan by saying that the people of Pakistan are like the people of India and like they are now doing by supporting Pakistani artistes. But whatever they say in India, Pakistani artistes cannot utter a word of praise for India once they are back in Pakistan because the likes of Hafiz Saeed will eliminate them pronto. Or they will be branded India-lovers, lose their fan following and face social taunts.

This support for Pakistani artistes to stay and work in India is based on two major premises: one, that sending them back will not solve the terrorist problem and two, they are here on Indian visas and stay here because the government has allowed them. People must realize that people to people contact with Pakistan has failed. For so many years, we have allowed these artistes to work in India. Have the terror attacks subsided? In fact, they have increased. So if allowing them to work here has not solved the terrorist problem, let us give banning them a try. In strategic warfare, this is one of the options – sending back nationals of unfriendly nations. I am sure people in Bollywood are not aware of this. The government should cancel their visas and send them back. If the government had given them visas, the government will cancel them. Bollywood should display sensitivity towards our soldiers and respect public opinion by not supporting Pakistani artistes. They should be allowed back only when there is a reciprocal arrangement whereby Indian artistes are also allowed to work freely in Pakistan (although one is sure not many will like to work there). Love, affection and friendship cannot be one-sided.