oppn parties WhatsApp Group Admin Not Vicariously Liable For Action of Members

Story Of The Day

D Gukesh Is The Youngest New Challenger For The World Chess Crown
OPINIONS : Strongly Expressed

April 25, 2024

People Are Talking About

Rohit Warns Sarfaraz, Police Use It To Warn Two-Wheeler Riders

News Snippets

  • Congress says party has nothing to do with Pitroda's inheritance tax views and they are his own private views
  • Commenting on Sam Pitroda's remarks on inheritance tax, PM Modi says Congress wants to loot citizens even after their death
  • Record 56 students get 100 percentile in JEE (main) exam this year
  • Supreme Court says it cannot pass the order regarding EVMs just based on speculation of manipulation
  • Speculation over Tej Pratap Yadav's candidature from Kannauj ended with the SP declaring that Akhilesh Yadav will contest from the constituency
  • Supreme Court says it will not go by 'Marxist interpretation' of wealth redistribution while looking at the ambit of Article 39(b) of Directive Principles of State Policy
  • With subdued rural demand hitting revenue (which remained flat), HUL's profit declined for the first time after Covid-hit March 20 quarter as it posted a reduced profit in Q4 FY23
  • Credit card spend hits record Rs 1L cr in March, up 20% YoY
  • RBI stops Kotak Mahindra Bank from issuing fresh credit cards or onboard new clients online after detecting 'serious deficiencies' in its IT system
  • Stocks remain positive on Wednesday: Sensex gains 114 points to 73852 and Nifty gains 34 points to 22402
  • Asian U-20 Athletics: Deepanshu Sharma and Rohan Yadav make it one-two in javelin throw
  • IPL: Delhi Captials beat Gujarat Titans as Rishabh Pant (88 of 43 balls) and Axar Patel (66) guide them to 224/4. GT try hard but fall short by 4 runs
  • Supreme Court allows a raped minor to end her 30-week pregnancy
  • Mamata Banerjee calls Calcutta HC order in teacher appointment "illegal" and "one-sided", state government to file appeal in Supreme Court
  • Calcutta HC scraps TM|C government's 2016 process of appointing school teachers, 25757 teachers set to lose their jobs and asked to return their salaries
Row over inheritance tax escalates: PM Modi says Congress wants to loot citizens even after their death. Congress distances itself from Sam Pitroda's remarks
oppn parties
WhatsApp Group Admin Not Vicariously Liable For Action of Members

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2021-12-28 08:27:39

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator.

The Madras High Court has confirmed that the admins of a WhatsApp group cannot be held vicariously liable for the actions of the members in the group due to the very nature of the application and the limited powers the app allows to them. The court cited the Bombay HC judgment on this issue in the case Kishor versus The State of Maharashtra to reiterate that since the administrator does not have the powers to regulate, moderate or censor the content posted by other members of the group, he or she cannot be held liable for their actions.

The case was about a WhatsApp group of lawyers in Tamil Nadu, called Karur Lawyers, a member of which filed a criminal case against the admin and a member over a "highly offensive" post by the latter. The admin approached the HC pleading innocence as it was not in his power to prevent some members from posting content found offensive by other members.

In the Bombay HC order cited by the court, the learned judges had ruled that the admin cannot be held for vicarious liability for the act of other members unless it was proved that "there was the common intention or pre-arranged plan acting in concert pursuant to such plan by such member of a WhatsApp group and the administrator."

This is the right legal interpretation. For, any WhatsApp administrator is only allowed by the makers of the app to admit new members or remove existing one, apart from changing the name, status and profile picture of the group or including other members as co-administrators. It is not in the hands of the admin to moderate, delete or censor any offending post which can only be done by one who originally posted. Hence, they cannot be held liable for something which is not in their power.

Other Stories You Make Like

Editorials

Citizens' Right To Know Versus Politicians' Right To Privacy And The Test Of Proportionality

Citizens' Right To Know Versus Politicians' Right To Privacy And The Test Of Proportionality

 India's Young Guns Come To The Fore

India's Young Guns Come To The Fore

In Depth

As Per Hindu Marriage Act, Saptapadi Essential, Not Kanyadaan Says Allahabad HC

As Per Hindu Marriage Act, Saptapadi Essential, Not Kanyadaan Says Allahabad HC

Editor's Pick

The BJP Crushes The Opposition By Any & All Means

The BJP Crushes The Opposition By Any & All Means
© 2014 India Commentary. All rights reserved.