oppn parties Kolkata Flyover Collapse: Definitely Not "An Act of God"

News Snippets

  • Uttarakhand HC says marital discord, suspicion and quarrels cannot be held to be abetment of suicide
  • Two sisters, both brides-to-be, died by suspected suicide in Jodhpur. No suicide note was found
  • RTI reveals that 200 big cats were poached in India between 2005 and 2025, with the most in MP
  • After the US Supreme Court order on tariffs, Centre has put Indian trade team's US visit on hold
  • Delhi Police bust terror module linked to Lashkar that was plotting to strike in Delhi. Arrest 7 Bangladeshis with Aadhar IDs
  • PM Modi announced in his Mann Ki Baat that Edwin Lutyens' statue will be replaced with that of C Rajagopalchari at the Rashtrapati Bhawan
  • Facial recognition at Digi Yatra gates in Kolkata Airport suffered prolonged glitch on Sunday, forcing passengers to wait in long queues
  • Ranji Final: Strong Karnataka take on rising J&K in the match starting from Tuesday
  • Rising Stars women's cricket: India 'A' beat Bangladesh by 46 runs to capture title
  • Super 8s: Co-hosts Sri Lanka lose too, England beat them by 51 runs
  • Super 8s: South Africa crush India by 76 runs as nothing goes right for the hosts
  • PM Modi inaugurates India's fastest metro in Meerut and the first Vande Bharat sleeper in Bengal, This sleeper will cover Howrah to Guwahati route
  • After his consecutive failures, Abhishek Sharma has created a problem for the team management: should they give him one more chance in a vital match today or go for Sanju Samson as opener
  • A Pocso court in Prayagraj ordered an FIR against Swami Avi Mukteshawaranand and his disciple Muktanand Giri for molesting underage boys in their Magh Mela camp
  • TOI reported that while private universities filed more patents, elite institutions like IIT and IISc got more approvals between 2020-2025
T20 World Cup Super 8s: India get a reality check, outplayed by South Africa in their first match, end 12-match winning streak
oppn parties
Kolkata Flyover Collapse: Definitely Not "An Act of God"

By Sunil Garodia
First publised on 2016-04-01 19:18:34

About the Author

Sunil Garodia Editor-in-Chief of indiacommentary.com. Current Affairs analyst and political commentator.
Kolkata is once again in the limelight for the wrong reason. The collapse of an under construction flyover is a serious matter. Apart from the loss of lives and property, harassment to people who stay in the locality and problems faced by commuters, it clearly shows that infrastructure projects are being built with a cavalier attitude by those who ‘win’ the bids.

The builders, IVRCL, first said that the collapse was an “act of God.” Then their legal head clarified that it meant the company had no control over what happened. Now they are saying that it might have happened due to a bomb blast. TMC MP Sudip Bandhopadhyay has hinted about faulty design. Others will say use of sub-standard material. Still others will say proper time for foundation to set was not given. There will be hundreds of accusations or excuses. But the fact is that it went down and an IIT, Kharagpur team is slated to enquire into the cause. Transparency should be maintained in the probe and the guilty should be handed out exemplary punishment.

Act of God it definitely was not. At least not the kind that happened in that brilliant movie OMG. The only lightening that struck hit the officials of the construction company, who are now claiming to be as surprised as the rest of us on why the collapse happened. But they have to provide the answers as they are the ones who are responsible.

It is too early to blame the TMC government as the construction work is going on for a long time and no mishaps were reported earlier. Other parties will obviously try to make political capital out of the issue in this election season. But years after the contract has been awarded, it can only be the misdeeds of the contractors or those who are working on the ground that can cause a mishap of this magnitude.

This collapse proves that contract awardees should not be left alone once they start constructing. There is a system of periodic checks of materials being used etc. but obviously that seems not to be enough. There is also an element of corruption as officials designated to collect and verify samples often allow dubious materials after taking a ‘cut.’ There should be a mechanism to monitor daily progress. If that is not possible, at least a high level regulatory presence should be there when main events, such a putting up pillars or installing overhead beams, is being done.

Both the government and the builders should leave their cavalier attitude aside and work towards first bringing the guilty to book and then ensuring that such things do not happen again, in this or any other project. It is the least the people of Kolkata can hope for.